I Want to Get Rid of My Fingerhut and Credit One Bank Cards


Dear Steve,

About three years ago, I acquired three credit cards – two from Credit One Bank and one from Fingerhut.

I only applied for these particular ones because I had a bankruptcy in 2011, wanted to build up my credit score again, and could not find any other companies who’d issue me one.

I don’t like the idea of “secured” credit cards. However, I was well aware that the interest rates were outrageously high, and in the case of Credit One Bank, I cringed at paying a yearly fee.

Additionally, I knew Fingerhut often charged three times that of other retailers for their products.

However, I knew I would only use these cards if I had to, which has been the case. By the way, it’s been over ten years, so my bankruptcy has now been removed from my credit bureau reports.

Now, I want to cancel all of these cards. I have zero balances on them and do not want to pay the fees anymore. Now that my credit score has increased (although not quite back up to where I want it), I have requested several times that Credit One Bank stop charging me fees and lower the interest rates.

They refuse to do so. I’m also sick of the constant condescending, bordering on harassing emails, text messages, USPS letters, etc., I get from Fingerhut hounding me to buy their absurdly high-priced products.

However, as you know, if I cancel these cards, my credit score will take a big hit. Is there any way to avoid this if I cancel the cards?

Also, I already subscribe to your site, so I don’t need to be added.



Dear Rachel,

Thank you for already being a subscriber.

Damon Day and I recently did a podcast that seems almost spot on regarding your situation. If you get a chance, listen to the podcast below. A lot of good tips and lessons in the podcast for you.

See also  Credit One Bank Platinum Visa Offer Review

Listen to the Podcast

You can subscribe to my podcast on any of these sites below.
Amazon Podcast  Apple Podcast  Castbox Podcasts  Google Podcasts  Overcast Podcasts    RadioPublic Podcast  Spotify  Stitcher Podcasts  Tune-In


I’m glad you are reaching out to me now. If I had a time machine, I would have jumped back to the day after your bankruptcy discharge, and we could have returned you to stellar credit a lot faster. There is no need to wait for bankruptcy to fall off a credit report before getting aggressive about rebuilding credit. See How to Easily Rebuild and Repair Your Credit After Bankruptcy. This strategy works everytime.

If you cancel all three cards, you will gut your score. So please don’t do that.

Store and retail cards like Fingerhut do nothing for you. Those you can certainly close. The Credit One Bank card has a lot of age on it now, and the length of your accounts is a significant factor in your credit score.

It sucks you are paying a hefty fee with Credit One Bank, but for now, it will be an investment in keeping your score up. A visit to the Credit One Bank website shows annual fees on cards from $0 to $99. Of course, the annual fee isn’t an issue if you are on a credit card that gives you rewards and perks you use. In your case, it’s a credit score boost.

Annual fees do not need to be avoided. For example, I have a credit card with a yearly fee of $495. That seems like a lot, and it is. However, I get so many perks, rewards, and free hotel stays that the fee ends up being free and I make money from having the card.

It’s too bad you “didn’t like the idea of a secured card” since it is such a brilliant way to rebuild credit.

By getting a secured card with a major credit card issuer like Capital One, Citibank, or Discover, you can move your way from a secured to an unsecured card and stay in the same bank.

See also  Credit One Bank Platinum Visa Offer Review

Oh, and never use a debit card. It is less safe to use than a credit card and does nothing to build credit.

One place to research new credit cards is your mailbox. Keep your eye open for the offers you may be receiving. Those are often an indication of Main Street lenders willing to take a chance on you.

However, I’d avoid American Express. Yuck.


You are not alone. I'm here to help. There is no need to suffer in silence. We can get through this. Tomorrow can be better than today. Don't give up.

Do you have a question you'd like to ask me for free? Go ahead and click here.

Damon Day - Pro Debt Coach

Follow Me
Steve Rhode is the Get Out of Debt Guy and has been helping good people with bad debt problems since 1994. You can learn more about Steve, here.
Steve Rhode
Follow Me

2 thoughts on “I Want to Get Rid of My Fingerhut and Credit One Bank Cards”

Leave a Comment