Latest Posts • Latest Episodes • Free Tools

Get Out of Debt Podcast – Answers for Angela and Her Concerns About Allegro Law

Quick Answer: Steve Rhode answers Angela, whose family got caught in the collapse of Allegro Law, a debt settlement operation shut down by Alabama's Attorney General, leaving client funds frozen in a court-controlled escrow account. He explains why debt settlement was never legally binding on her creditors in the first place, why forgiven settled debt can trigger a surprise tax bill, and why bankruptcy is the one legal tool that stops collection activity immediately and can resolve the situation in weeks instead of years.

Listen to this episode:

Duration: 10 min

Dealing With Debt? Understanding your options is the first step. See how all your debt relief options compare — including ones most sites won’t tell you about. The Find Your Path quiz gives a recommendation based on your actual numbers, and the Scam-O-Meter checks any company’s complaint history before you sign. Federal Reserve research shows bankruptcy filers recover faster than those who don’t file.

Free Tool — Contract Decoder: Have a contract from a debt relief company? The free Contract Decoder analyzes it for red flags, hidden fees, and problematic terms — before you sign anything. Decode My Contract →

Key Takeaways

  • Allegro Law was an Alabama law firm selling debt settlement, serviced by AmeriCor in New York. The Alabama Attorney General found its services were not in compliance with the law, and the attorney running it lost his law license for three years.
  • Allegro Law customers are stuck in the middle: fees they paid are probably gone, and money in escrow is frozen under a court-appointed receiver until a court order releases it.
  • Debt settlement is not a legally binding solution on your creditors. Nothing stops them from calling, collecting, and suing you while you are in a program.
  • More often than not, your first year of payments to a debt settlement company goes to the company's fees, and your creditors get little to nothing.
  • Bankruptcy is the only legally binding tool that gives you leverage and control, makes the collection calls stop almost immediately, and protects you from lawsuits.
  • If you are behind and creditors are chasing you, your credit score will recover faster with bankruptcy than with debt settlement, because bankruptcy stops the collection activity now.
  • A Chapter 13 bankruptcy lets you keep your home and car with a payment plan based on what you can afford, and the debt left at the end is wiped out with no tax liability, unlike forgiven debt in a settlement.

Full Transcript

Click to expand transcript

Don’t be embarrassed, and trust me, don’t be ashamed. Everything you say to me, baby, is confidential. I know this is really intimate stuff, but… let’s talk about debt. Coming to you again with more help is your Get Out of Debt Guy, your man with the answers to solve all your financial worries, your host and debt expert, Steve Rhode. Hi, this is Steve Rhode, your Get Out of Debt Guy. Well, today we’ve got another call in on the recorded helpline, and you can call and leave a message if you want. If you have any concern, question, feedback, anything that you need help with to help you to get out of debt, I am here for you. And the number for you to call if you have a question is 919-321-2378. You’ll be prompted to leave your name, your first name, and your question, and then I’ll answer it on the next podcast. I always answer recorded messages before I get to the written messages. So if you have a question you want answered quickly, call me, 919-321-2378. Well, today’s message comes from Angela. Angela and her husband unfortunately got caught up in the whole Allegro Law debt settlement mess, and I want you to listen to Angela’s message, and then we’ll talk about it. Hey, buddy, you’re listening to the Get Out of Debt Radio Show, and if you don’t remember that this ain’t legal or accounting advice, I’ll have to hurt you. For real legal advice, find yourself a lawyer in your state. Got it? Hi Steve, my name is Angela. My problem is I called to the Achievable about a year ago as my husband had huge debts after he’d had a failed business venture, and we were really struggling at the time. I called looking for a solution, and I was advised that debt settlement would be the best solution for us. We were referred to Allegro Law, who I know you know about; we don’t need to explain that to you. What happened in the past few weeks is obviously all of this happened. We had money with Allegro Law. One of our debts was settled, but there is still money outstanding that was paid to them. We have written to the Attorney General, and in all honesty, it’s not really our biggest concern. Our biggest concern is how we move forward from here. We still have all those debts. All the creditors are calling us now. We’re in a situation where we can’t possibly settle in the way that they are asking of us. Many of them want to settle with us, but we can’t afford the large payments upfront that they’re looking for in order to do that. So we need to find a new solution. I’m hoping you can help us with this, or tell us where we can go for the help that we need. I would appreciate it. Thank you. Bye. Thank you for calling, Angela. Leave me your message. It’s just so incredibly sad how many people have been caught up in this mess with Allegro Law. Allegro Law was a law firm in Alabama that was providing debt settlement services. These accounts were being serviced by a company in New York called AmeriCor, and AmeriCor services debt settlement and debt management accounts for several other companies as well. The problem is that the Attorney General in the state of Alabama determined that the services provided by Allegro Law were not in compliance with the law. And in fact, the attorney that was running the law practice actually wound up losing his law license for three years. The problem is that all of the customers have been stuck and stranded in the middle. They have money that has been paid in fees that they are probably not going to recover, and they have money that is being held in an escrow account that is now under the control of the receiver who was appointed by the court. But it requires a court order to release that money. So people are stuck in the middle. But I think this, what this does gives us an opportunity to talk about the flaws and problems with debt settlement. I understand why reaching out to a solution where you think that you’re going to only pay 50% or 40% of the money that you owe sounds like it is a good idea to get you out of debt. But the problem, Angela, and everyone, the problem here is that when you go into debt settlement, it is not a legally binding solution on your creditors. While you are promised that things are going to get better, there is nothing in this world that will prevent your creditors from continuing to collect, making collection calls, contacting you, and suing you. And if you’re working with a debt settlement company, you’re sending monthly payments to that debt settlement company. More often than not, those initial payments, that first year payments, is going to the debt settlement company fees, and your creditors are getting little to nothing. Or the debt settlement company will tell you, Well, send us X number of dollars a month, and then at the same time, we want you to put aside Y number of dollars a month in a savings account so that you build it up and you’ll have money to save. Well, they know that you’re not going to do that. You’re going to pay them fees, and then when they get an agreement from your creditor, you’re not going to have the money. So, the only legally binding solution that gives you any leverage, any control, that allows you to make the collection calls stop almost immediately and protects you from lawsuit is bankruptcy. I know bankruptcy sounds scary. It sounds horrible. But if you look at it as a tool, this is why corporations use it when they get into trouble. You know, when a corporation goes bankrupt, we don’t have any sort of stigma about it. We still fly the airlines, we still eat at the restaurants or whatever. I’m not asking you to consider bankruptcy as an indication of your moral failure. I’m asking you to consider bankruptcy as the only legally binding tool that you have to make this situation get better instantly. Instead of saving money for the next four years to try to settle a debt, you can resolve this situation within a week with bankruptcy. And you can recover from bankruptcy faster, actually, faster than you can from debt settlement. Your credit score, since you’re behind and creditors are chasing you, your credit score will get better faster with bankruptcy if you file bankruptcy now, because it’ll stop that collection activity. So, Angela, I urge you to look for a local bankruptcy attorney. Make some phone calls. Find an office that you enjoy talking to, that you think would be good to work with, and then call and schedule a free bankruptcy appointment, a free bankruptcy consultation. Not to go in to file bankruptcy. I want you to go in and talk to the attorney about your situation, ask every question that you can think of, and then go home, think it over, and think, does this apply to my situation? Isn’t this the solution that I’m looking for? Now, the concern is that people often have, I’m going to lose my car or my home or something else. The answer to that is no, you’re not. If you have a home and you have a car, you want to keep it, you can keep it through bankruptcy. There are solutions that can be worked out. You can file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which is where you have a payment plan that’s based upon what you can afford to pay. And ultimately, isn’t that what you’re trying to do? At the end of your Chapter 13 bankruptcy, let’s say that you repay 40% of your debt. At the end of your Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the rest of the debt will be wiped off, and you have no tax liability, like you often do with debt settlement. What the debt settlement companies don’t tell you is that any forgiven debt is a taxable exposure to you. You might have to pay income tax on it, just as if you earned the money. And they’ll say, Well, you don’t have to do that because you’re insolvent. But what the tax code says is, if your forgiven debt leaves you solvent, then you have to pay income tax on the difference between where you would have been insolvent and solvent. Don’t worry about the technicalities. Just know that debt settlement still leaves you with bad credit, takes you longer to recover from, leaves you exposed to lawsuits and bad credit information and collections, and bankruptcy is the legal option that you have to address this issue now and start to rebuild your life now, rather than waiting five years from now to do it. All right, Angela, thank you so much. I’m sending you a big audio hug for calling, and I wish you the best. Be sure to get back in touch with me or leave a comment under this question that’ll appear on the website under this podcast if you have any more questions or follow-up. Thank you. Thanks for listening to another Get Out of Debt show with your friend and mine, Steve Rhode. If you or someone you know would like to submit a question for Steve to answer, just visit our website at getoutofdebt.org and fill out the question form. And while you’re on the getoutofdebt.org site, be sure to subscribe to the show feed and—what’s that, Steve? Remember Twitter. Oh yes, follow Steve on Twitter at GetOutOfDebtGuy.

Free Tool — Scam-O-Meter: Considering a debt relief company? Run your situation through the free Scam-O-Meter — it checks for official FTC, FBI, CFPB, and SEC warning signs before you hand over any money. Check for Red Flags →

The part the headline left out

Each weekday I send one short email: one story that caught my attention, why it might matter to you, and one manageable thing you can do with it. A couple of minutes, and a dad joke.

In the latest issue (Nov 13): The shelf price isn't always what you pay

Free. I sell nothing. Unsubscribe any time.

Or read a few issues first

Frequently Asked Questions

What happened to the money Allegro Law customers had paid in?

In 2009 I said a court-appointed receiver controlled Allegro Law customers' escrow money, that it needed a court order to be released, and that fees already paid were probably not coming back. In February 2010, an Alabama court issued a permanent injunction and agreed Allegro had violated Alabama's Deceptive Trade Practices Act and Sale of Checks Act.

Why did I say debt settlement was not the answer once creditors were calling?

In 2009 I said a settlement company's plan does not bind a creditor that has not agreed to it, so that creditor can still call or sue you. I still think bankruptcy usually wins, and filing brings the automatic stay. Since October 27, 2010, a federal rule has barred companies selling debt relief by phone from charging a fee on a debt until it is settled or changed and you have made at least one payment under the deal.

Will I lose my home or car if I file bankruptcy?

In 2009 I told a listener that people who want to keep a home and a car often can: in Chapter 7 if exemptions cover the equity and you keep up the loan payments, or in a Chapter 13 plan that catches up missed payments over time. A Chapter 13 discharge generally comes when you finish the plan. My advice today: ask a local bankruptcy attorney how your state's exemptions and liens apply.

author avatar
Steve Rhode The Get Out of Debt Guy | Consumer Debt Expert
Consumer debt expert & investigative writer. Personal bankruptcy survivor (1990). Washington Post award-winning author. Exposing debt scams since 1994.