Latest Posts • Latest Episodes • Free Tools

So Much Debt Advice is Just Not as Simple as We Want

Quick Answer: Steve Rhode and Damon Day answer a reader's question about a car with a blown transmission and $25,000 still owed, walking through when to call the lender first, when selling the car yourself beats a voluntary repossession, and how a deficiency balance left after a repossession can later be settled or handled in bankruptcy. Damon shares his own experience negotiating a voluntary repossession from the other side of the table, plus a client case where timing a new car purchase before the repossession made the numbers work out better.

Listen to this episode:

Duration: 26 min

Dealing With Debt? Understanding your options is the first step. See how all your debt relief options compare — including ones most sites won’t tell you about. The Find Your Path quiz gives a recommendation based on your actual numbers, and the Scam-O-Meter checks any company’s complaint history before you sign. Federal Reserve research shows bankruptcy filers recover faster than those who don’t file.

Free Tool — Contract Decoder: Have a contract from a debt relief company? The free Contract Decoder analyzes it for red flags, hidden fees, and problematic terms — before you sign anything. Decode My Contract →

Key Takeaways

  • Debt is math wrapped in emotion—address both to find lasting solutions.
  • Taking action on debt, even small steps, builds momentum toward financial freedom.
  • Your financial situation today doesn't define your future—change is always possible.
  • Getting professional help isn't a sign of failure; it's a smart strategy.
  • Every debt situation is unique—find what fits your circumstances.
  • The emotional burden of debt often outweighs the financial burden—addressing both is essential.
  • Understanding all your options, including the uncomfortable ones, leads to better decisions.

Full Transcript

Click to expand transcript

Hey, you’re back with the Get Out of Debt Guy, Steve Rhode, and the new-ish Get Out of Debt Guy, Damon Day. And today we’re talking about a question that I got and answered about repossessions. And it’s funny, Damon. You know, somebody can ask you a pretty simple question. And all of a sudden, it exposes the complexities of meeting good debt help. Now, the question was, this guy had a car. It was a used car. The warranty had run out on it. And his transmission was having issues. And he wanted to know if he should turn the car in and buy a new car. You know, have it voluntarily repossessed. And he said that he talked to the dealer and they were of no help. He wondered if he should talk to his lender. He should talk to the guy that calls and says, hey, I’ve been trying to reach you about your car’s warranty. The extended warranty. Yeah. Well, you know, the interesting thing about this situation is I, you or myself can provide all the advice in the world for a reader question. But the reality is that these situations are just much more complex than a textbook answer because they never take into account the complexities of people’s individual lives. And this is what makes me laugh, Damon. When people pick up phone and they call a credit counselor or debt settlement company or somebody like that whenever they have been a financial problem, the counselor, the salesperson is quick to give them the canned answer. This is exactly what you need to do. But oh my God, in all my years, every situation is different. How about you? Yes. Well, thank you for joining us today on. Doctor, doctor, I concur. Well, let’s talk about that. Okay. Just giving Steve fits today. No, hey, nobody likes the repo man. But you know, you gave a pretty concise and good, well thought out answer. In your video, you and I don’t think ever give textbook answers to anything. I think people could agree with that. Now, there are times where a voluntary repo can make sense. But as you pointed out in your video, it should definitely not be the first thing you look at. Yeah. So the video Damon’s talking about is over on YouTube, I have this channel called old guy insights where I answer questions for people on a wide variety of topics, not just money things. And this guy’s got this guy’s got like 12,000 subscribers and less like a month on this new channel. But today’s, today’s my, YouTube lottery. I don’t know what he’s doing over there, but holy moly go check it out old guy insights. You’re probably yelling. I’m like everybody else. Oh, yeah, please feel free. Uh, today’s, I actually had somebody that we yelled at me over the weekend in the comments. And they told me that what I was saying was not true. And I should stop line. And my response was you should stop not fact checking. But was that your video on fact checking? No. Oh, that’s why you did the video on fact check. That is why I did the video. Yeah. Uh, but. So, uh, yeah, the question I answered today was all about should I buy a used car, which kind of falls into this in a bit. So the, I thought what really struck me with that question that I was asked about the should I turn my car in? I haven’t talked to the lender yet is. What’s the downside of talking to the lender? I mean, if you’re late, they already know you’re late. Uh, if you’re going to fall behind, they’re going to know it soon. So I have had in the past when I was working with clients, I certainly have had my share of people who. Uh, call or I on their behalf, talk to their lender and. Got a surprise response. I mean, probably one of the most surprising was. I had a client where the lender, she, she was in a lease and the lender allowed her to assign her lease to somebody else rather than fall behind on it, which I thought they never did. You know, especially post COVID, lenders act very different now, I think, than they did pre COVID. And, you know, you kind of see it even when the, uh, when, when everything went to crap and, you know, oh eight, you saw that too. Like, you know, lenders adjust policies all the time. Yeah. Usually coinciding with how bad their books are looking. They tend to be like, our books are really ugly right now. Let’s be nicer and be a little bit more flexible with people that are still trying to send us money. Well, I find that there are some basic rules. Uh, if you’re going to. The bottom line on the question about the repossession was. Don’t be afraid of your lender. So I, I kind of want to focus on that. They don’t want to repo the car. No. And so here’s the thing. If, if you’re feeling intimidated or stressed or embarrassed about your situation and you’re picking up the phone, please realize that you’re going to be on edge. You might get somebody from the lender side who answers the phone might not be very courteous, might be kind of rude or abrupt. Instead of yelling at them and getting upset and say they’re not going to do anything. Plenty hang up the phone. You know, say goodbye. And I think that’s the exception. What people have a rude, have a rude customer service. Oh, I agree. But you know, when you’re on edge. Yeah, even your interpretation might be off. Exactly. Exactly. So don’t be afraid to, you know, lightly say goodbye and then call back later and get somebody else, especially with the big lenders. It’s very unlikely you’re going to get the same person twice. And you’re going to get further by politely explaining the situation and asking for their help and cooperation. And what can you do? Because Damon, you’ve, you’ve been the king of being able to get amazing things just by asking. I call it the Jerry McWire approach. Help me help you. I mean, that’s essentially that’s what you’re trying to do. Like, hey, look, Mr. Lender, I’m in a bad way. And you’re in this with me, whether you want to be or not. So help me help you. You can help me a little bit. I’ll try to help you back by giving you some money, but I can’t give you exactly what you want. Here’s what I can do. Yeah, right. Well, take the Jerry McWire thing a little bit further. They want to yell at you. Show me the money. Yes. Show me the money. So also what I thought was really interesting about this question was the guy said that his transmission was having problems. And that’s why he was going to give the car back and try to buy another car. Yeah. The he owed 25 grand on this four year old Impala that now had a bag the car back and try to buy five grand or less. It’s a broken car. You know what doesn’t have transmissions horses. Tesla’s. That’s true. But you know, he’s going to end up with a big deficiency judgment and they’re going to come after him for the balance that’s out. Let’s call it 20 grand. And so now he’s going to have to deal with that too. So I think we helpful. Let’s get into those different options. You did talk about those options on the old guy insights channel. But let’s say you’re you know, you’re struggling. You know, you’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. You’re struggling with the car. The kingdom’s life. The volume of walking before the car. historical stepped back. The volume of walking before the car. The volume of walking before the car. But this is whatcountry遇完. Abd~! With a volume of people kicking around. With a volume of people kicking around. With a volume of people kicking around. That volume of people kicking around. That volume of people kicking around. That volume of people kicking around. That volume of people kicking around. With a volume of people beating around. With a volume of people beating around. Make sure we got this number right. But the volume of people beating around. Make sure we get this number right. Make sure you get this number right. Make sure you get this number right. Make sure you get this number right? current on the payments. So it’s best to call before you actually fall behind, even though that seems asked backwards. But yeah, so sometimes you might be in a situation where like yeah, we’ll give you a skip of payment, but you have to make this last payment that you missed first and then we’ll let you skip next month, right? So call before you fall behind if you can, but definitely talk to the lender, look at all of your options. They’re not gonna go right to a loan modification right away. They usually have some kind of forbearance options or something like that. A lot of lenders have them available once a year, a skip of payment, right? So just call and ask what’s available. Maybe doing that ever since I was an adult. That was when they had horses, no trimissants. Yeah. You know, in this first and situation, the options that they had available, the voluntary repossession is the worst of the options because you know, you can get your transmission repaired or even replaced with a used transmission, which the transmission place will warranty for you. And replacing it with a used transmission is gonna be between two and $3,000. Yeah, but there are situations where, you know, you might have no credit left. You might already max out on all your cards. And you just don’t even, even though it’s cheaper, you don’t have two or $3,000. You have a broken car and maybe you need that car to get to work. So there’s times where it’s just like, it’s not an option. They can’t, maybe because of their credit, they cannot find any kind of financing. You know, you wanna go to the repair shop and they go, yeah, we offer financing. Well, they don’t offer financing. They offer a pamphlet that you can call a bank and the bank offers financing, not the actual repair shop. You know, right? So there are times where you just, maybe you’re not in a situation where you can get that transmission fixed. Okay, so let’s talk about this guy in this situation. If he lets cargo, let’s cargo. So if he lets the cargo, then let’s say it’s a $20,000 deficiency judgment. And he doesn’t have the money, he doesn’t have two or three grand to fix the transmission. And that’s what a chapter seven bankruptcy might cost him up front if he’s gonna go do that. So what is your advice in this specific situation? What should he do first? Well, so he’s already talked to the lender now and the lender is like, you know, tough luck, right? So sad, not gonna do anything. If he has no possible way to, because I agree with you, getting the transmission fixed, if you’re looking at a potential $20,000 deficiency, which you might be in this situation, the next thing to do, if you absolutely cannot get the transmission fixed, will be to try to sell it yourself. Now it’s not gonna be easy, because in this case, you got a broken car, but you might be able to get more than $5,000 for it, but the problem is, unless that person’s willing to somehow give you the $25,000 and carry back a note for, let’s say somebody would be willing to make a mechanic, a mechanic special. You willing to buy it for 10 grand, now you’re gonna have to come up with 15, so if you’re gonna have to come up with 15. So the only way to do that would be like, well, I’ll sell it to you for 10, but I need 25. Yeah, because if you don’t get the title, you don’t have anything to sell. So unless you’re an excellent negotiator, that’s gonna be a hard route. So you may be in a situation where a voluntary repo is really kind of your only option. Unfortunately, if you have no access to cash, right? Yeah. So you might now, whether, now what’s gonna happen? If you end up, you go down that path, you eventually get this deficiency judgment that Steve’s talking about. Well, now that’s a separate thing. Cars gone, again, that’s the last resort. You don’t want to repo it if you can get it sold, or you can work with the bank, but if you have to, now you have to treat this just like any other debt. Now you’ve got this, whatever it is, $15,000, $20,000, you get the bill from the bank. This is gonna be five months later, six months later, could be a year later. Sometimes these things don’t happen that fast. And now you’ve got this $20,000. Well, now that’s a whole separate issue. How do we deal with this unsecured $20,000 note that they’re wanting to collect on? Whether you negotiate and settle that later, maybe you’re in a better financial position by the time you get this debt. Maybe it’s a year later, and now maybe you’re back on your feet, you’re making more money, whatever it is, you can work with the lender on that, or the collector to settle it, maybe a chapter seven bankruptcy does make sense. So it just depends on your overall situation, but if you can’t hold onto the car, and you have to let them repull it, you can, but just be prepared that whatever, how far upside down you think you are, it’s gonna be a lot more when you get that bill. Because the lender doesn’t care about getting top dollar for that car. They’re gonna just put it out there to a wholesaler, and that wholesaler is gonna buy it at a price where they can make sure make money. Yeah, I mean, so let’s picture exactly what happens. The car doesn’t, the car gets pushed through the auction barn. And I use car dealer, if it’s, you know, in reasonably good shape, a use car dealer is going to buy it, but they’re only going to pay enough where they still can make a good profit even after they fixed the transmission. Yeah. So you should have no expectation. And they’re buying a blind. They don’t know that that’s the only problem either. Because they can’t go test drive it before they buy it. So there, you know, the thing is, sell it before the transmission breaks. Yeah. Thank you for that one, no stradamus. So you know that you’re not gonna get top dollar at all. And so even if you, let’s say you do give it back, you have a deficiency judgment, you could do a bankruptcy down the road. It’s always an option. And Damon, I’ve been very remiss in not reminding people that the way they get in touch with you is by going to your amazing website at… Well, if you see my website, you’ll know I’m an awesome financial advisor because I’m a shitty web designer. I built that website like 15 years ago and haven’t. It’s so old, a lot of my testimonials, the plug-in is broken and I haven’t even fixed that. So it’s like, No, it’s so old that the little kids sitting on your lap are all grown up in a high school. Well, my 11 year old daughter is not even in the photo. Yeah. And my, and my oldest too, I’m holding his hand is graduating this year from high school. So proud. I don’t think I can still log into my website. I’m sure I’m not that fast. So, to reach Damon, go to Damon Day, D-A-N-O-N-D-A-Y.com and take a look at this, little kids pictures. Look at me a while. All right. Younger and slimmer. I like those photos. That’s true. But if Steve was in the photo, he’d have hair. A full beard, I’d have hair. Yeah. Steve used to look like me. Yeah. All right. So don’t panic if you’re in this situation. Get some good advice. The reason I brought up your website, Damon, is because when somebody’s in a situation like this, it’s probably the first time they’ve been there. They don’t know what they don’t know. They’re afraid and embarrassed and everything else. At least they can reach out to you. And you’re not going to judge them at all. And you’re going to help guide them through. Hey, here’s what the possible options are. And you’re then going to let them make what they think is the best decision for them. Yeah. You’re not there to force somebody what to do. Yeah. And a lot of the stuff I learned by going through it myself, I did a voluntary repo on a big fifth wheel trailer back in 08. Oh, this is when everything crashed, right? And I think it was, oh wait, it might have been 09. By the time I did the voluntary repo. But I knew I was going to be filing for bankruptcy. Not because of the trailer, because everything else that was going on. So the funny thing about that was, I called up the lender. And I was in a different state at the time. And they were like, look for it. It’s like four or five months behind. They were looking for this trailer. And I called them up. And well, here’s the thing. They were sneaky because I called them up. And I told them I was working on it and da, da, da, da. And they said, OK, no problem. We’ll give you time. Blah, blah, blah. I can’t remember all the details. But I remember them telling me, no problem. We’ll work with you. And then I can’t remember how I found out. But there was a guy somehow called me that knew, like, I don’t know. There was a name mix up or something. The guy was going through a trailer park, looking for, in a different state, looking for my trailer, which was in storage at my house. I don’t know how. I don’t know. Anyway, but I found out that the bank was kind of being sneaky. But this was back in 08. And so I called him up. And I was like, hey, I thought you guys said you’d work with me. And they’re, of course, playing dumb. And so anyway, I said, well, look, I’m not going to play these games. Just come get the trailer. That’s fine. Come get it. Now this was a big 40 foot, fifth wheel, 20,000 pound RV. Not just something you just swing by and grab. So I remember I made the arrangement. Hey, here’s where it’s at. I’ll meet the guy there, whatever. Made all the arrangements. The guy comes up. It looks at the trailer and he goes, I can’t tow that. This sucker’s so big, it’s repo proof. It’s too big to tow. So anyway, he talked about me negotiating stuff. So I said, well, I’ll tell you what. I’ll tow it to your yard for you for $500. OK. Cash? Yeah. And he looks at me and he’s like, are you serious? You’re killing me. I’m like, well, you can tow it. He’s like, I don’t have a truck big enough to pull this. And I bet you don’t have the right hitch connection either, because it’s a specialized hitched on there. He goes, it’s only 15 miles away. He goes 400 bucks. Not done. All right. So I hitched it up and towed it to the yard for him. And then I ended up, months later, I got a bill for, I don’t remember, 20 or 25 grand. But it was just included in the eventual bankruptcy that I filed. Yeah. So I ended up getting paid $400 to voluntarily repo. I’m like, thanks. Well, you see, because falling shit come out smelling like a rose. Well, over the years, I’ve had dozens of clients who eventually went the voluntary reposition route because, as I advise them, look, at least have some control over the situation. Yeah. That’s what you know the people. Yeah, all the people that had cars repot and like, my medicine was in it or something else. At least you’re in control of the situation. Well, you watch those guys on the shows chasing down the tow truck like, no, no. We’re trying to drive their truck back off. Oh, oh, truck. Yeah, damage it and everything else. That’s not making it better, bro. All right. Is there anything else we need to add to this particular situation? I thought there was. So let me recap the things you can ask the lender for, loan modification, deferment, or forbearance refinancing. Yeah, I know. I was going to add this other quick story a client I had years ago. It doesn’t always have to be a broken transmission that you can’t get out of the car, right? Let’s say you’re not behind on the car, you’re not really upside down or maybe just a tiny bit, but you realize the payment is just too large and you can’t, it’s just pulling you down. And you can’t hold on to it. That would be an option where getting it sold could really help, especially if you’re not really that far upside down and the car’s running and just getting it sold before you just let it go, right? So try to sell it. So I had a client one time. He was in a really nice car and he was getting up there in his years about to retire. And he only used this car as like a $14, $1500 with car payment, really, really nice Mercedes. He only drove it a couple of miles each day to work him back and that was really it. Yeah. And he didn’t need this kind of car, especially with what he was going through financially and with his wife and everything from a medical standpoint. So what I had advised him to do was buy a new car, right? Another car, but a $40,000 car, not a $120,000 car, whatever it was. And because he was upside down like, I don’t know, five or 10, he could not sell that car, right? So we did the voluntary repo, but he bought the new car first while his credit was still good. Bought the new car, it dropped the payment down to like $400 a month rather than $1400 a month. Here’s your car back. And then he drove the car back to the dealership and gave it back to him. Yeah, right? So now what eventually happened with that was we knew he was going to be filing bankruptcy, but we were just waiting for him to officially retire because his income was going to drop sufficiently to where once he was retired. And then his retirement income was all protected in the bankruptcy anyway. And then so it is what it is. I mean, he got a bill for, I think it was $40,000 or $50,000 for that car, but he couldn’t afford it. I mean, he just couldn’t afford it. And again, I’m not saying that’s the goal when you buy a car like that, but his circumstances changed from when he had bought the car to where we were at now. And that was the thing that made the most sense for him financially because his focus at that point was making sure he had enough funds to care for his wife. She needed around the clock in home care. And all the sudden that really nice car was not important anymore. You know, the other thing that struck me from reading the question was, I really felt like, you know, he was 25 grand underwater on a used vehicle that he had purchased. He must have been underwater when he bought that car and rolled the negative equity into it because- People do that a lot. I mean, that’s just pretty common because dealers want to sell you a car. So you go in there and they’re like, oh, you’re already upside. Oh, don’t worry about that. We’ll see if we can get the sucker of the bank into funds in this extra $10,000. They get paid on the transaction. They could care less whether or not you can, the salesperson could give two shits if you can’t make the payment six months from now. That’s not a problem. He got paid. Yeah. So the moment that you do that initially, just roll negative equity into a new car loan. It never, it never ends well because you’re going to be upside down. The car is going to get worn out or have a problem or something and you’re going to owe more than the car’s worth. Just please never, ever, ever do that. When you roll negative equity into the car, you’re just delaying the voluntary repo. Yeah. Yeah. It’s going to push that off for a few more years. Yeah, it’s good. That’s like with the butterfly flapped its wings, right? My favorite is these sales guy. Because I’ve been pulling trailers pretty much my whole life. That’s what we like to do. We like to go camping all that kind of stuff and we go all over the place in them. My favorite is the sales don’t ever, ever, ever, ever listen to the salesperson and he goes, what kind of trailer do you have? Oh yeah, this truck will tow it. Yeah. It never will tow it. This is the truck that I have and I want you to buy. So no matter what kind of trailer, how big it is, how heavy it is, I will tell you this half-tun will tow it. No problem. Yeah, this half-tun’s rated for 20,000 pounds? Sure. Go ahead and do it. Single wheel? No problem. No problem. A little F-150. Whatever those, what are those new ones called? The Mini Ford pickup trucks? I don’t know. I don’t play with toy truck Steve. Ha ha ha ha. All right, Damon. Unless there’s anything else until next time. See ya. If it ain’t a duly, it ain’t a truck. Peace.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I use my retirement savings to pay off debt?

Almost never. Retirement accounts are protected in bankruptcy and from creditors. Cashing out means paying taxes plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty, and you lose decades of compound growth.

The part the headline left out

Each weekday I send one short email: one story that caught my attention, why it might matter to you, and one manageable thing you can do with it. A couple of minutes, and a dad joke.

In the latest issue (Nov 11): I let AI shop my insurance. I saved $2,000.

Free. I sell nothing. Unsubscribe any time.

Or read a few issues first

How do I know which debt solution is right for me?

The best solution depends on your specific situation: income stability, debt amount, asset protection needs, and goals. Consult with a bankruptcy attorney (free consultations) before deciding.

Will creditors sue me if I stop paying?

They can. Not every creditor does, but never count on it. Ignore a lawsuit and the creditor usually wins a default judgment, which can lead to a bank levy and, in many states, a garnished paycheck. Open court papers the day they come, because the deadline to respond can be very short. Talk to a bankruptcy attorney before it passes. Filing generally brings an automatic stay that stops the lawsuit, and the discharge can wipe out debts like this.

Free Tool — I'm Being Sued for Debt Guide: Being sued by a creditor or debt collector? The free I'm Being Sued Guide gives you a personalized action plan — deadlines, defenses, and options based on your state. Most states require a response within 20–30 days. Get My Action Plan →

How long does debt stay on my credit report?

Most negative information stays for 7 years. Bankruptcy Chapter 7 stays for 10 years, Chapter 13 for 7 years. The impact diminishes over time.

Should I pay off debt or save for emergencies first?

Keep a cushion first. I want you to have at least three months of living expenses set aside, because without it the next car repair or lost paycheck can sink you. Keep paying rent or mortgage and the car, do not drain savings to pay other debt, and do not cash out retirement to pay collectors. If your debts leave no room for that cushion, see a bankruptcy attorney and tell them about your savings, so you know what you can keep.

author avatar
Steve Rhode The Get Out of Debt Guy | Consumer Debt Expert
Consumer debt expert & investigative writer. Personal bankruptcy survivor (1990). Washington Post award-winning author. Exposing debt scams since 1994.