Why Does Paying More Than the Minimum Stop Working?
You’ve heard the advice a thousand times: just pay more than the minimum and you’ll get out of debt. For someone with $5,000 in credit card debt, that’s probably fine advice. But if you’re carrying $80,000 or more in unsecured debt, paying more than the minimum isn’t a strategy — it’s a slow-motion disaster.
“At that level, just pay more than the minimum isn’t a strategy. It’s a slow-motion disaster.”
— Steve Rhode
The math is brutal. At high balances with credit card interest rates, most of your extra payment gets consumed by interest charges. You watch the balance barely move month after month, year after year.
Each weekday I send one short email: one story that caught my attention, why it might matter to you, and one manageable thing you can do with it. A couple of minutes, and a dad joke.
In the latest issue (Nov 6): Owed money on an Amazon return? Check by Dec. 1
Free. I sell nothing. Unsubscribe any time.
What Is the Real Cost of Staying in Debt?
Here’s what nobody talks about: the money you’re spending on debt payments isn’t just gone — it’s money that could be building your retirement. Many people are spending $3,000 to $4,000 per month on unsecured debt and vehicle payments while putting nothing into savings or retirement.
That’s the hidden math. The real cost of your debt isn’t the interest rate — it’s the retirement you’re not building.
Why Do 22% of Americans Think They’ll Never Get Out?
A recent study found that 22% of Americans believe they’ll never escape credit card debt. Steve and Damon argue that’s because most of them have already tried the conventional advice — pay more, cut back, consolidate — and watched it fail.
“That’s why — because they’ve probably tried multiple times and it never works out. So we have to start broadening our horizons.”
Do Big Companies Use Bankruptcy?
The parent company that owns Saks Fifth Avenue, Neiman Marcus, and Bergdorf Goodman recently used bankruptcy as a financial tool. These aren’t small struggling businesses — they’re billion-dollar corporations that understand bankruptcy is a legitimate strategy, not a moral failure.
If it’s good enough for them, why do we shame individuals for considering the same option?
What Should You Do Instead?
The first step is running the numbers on your own debt. Use a compound interest calculator and see how long it actually takes to pay off your balance at your current rate. The answer will probably shock you.
The second step is getting complete information. Talk to someone who can show you all your options — not just the one that keeps you paying for the next 25 years.
This Show Is For You
The Get Out of Debt Guy Show drops weekly with Steve Rhode and Damon Day. No judgment, no shame — just math and truth. If you need to talk to someone about your specific situation, visit DamonDay.com for a free consultation. Damon is co-host of the Get Out of Debt Guy podcast, and Steve receives no payment for this referral.
Dealing With Debt? Understanding your options is the first step. See how all your debt relief options compare — including ones most sites won’t tell you about. The Find Your Path quiz gives a recommendation based on your actual numbers, and the Scam-O-Meter checks any company’s complaint history before you sign. Federal Reserve research shows bankruptcy filers recover faster than those who don’t file.
Free Tool — Contract Decoder: Have a contract from a debt relief company? The free Contract Decoder analyzes it for red flags, hidden fees, and problematic terms — before you sign anything. Decode My Contract →
Key Takeaways
- Paying more than the minimum works for small debts under $5,000 but becomes a slow-motion disaster at $80,000 or more in unsecured debt.
- At high balances, most of your extra payment goes to interest, meaning the balance barely moves even when you pay more than required.
- 22% of Americans believe they will never escape credit card debt, often because they have tried the pay-more strategy multiple times and failed.
- Many people spend $3,000 to $4,000 per month on unsecured debt and vehicle payments while contributing nothing to retirement savings.
- Bankruptcy is used by major corporations like the parent company of Saks Fifth Avenue, Neiman Marcus, and Bergdorf Goodman as a legitimate financial tool.
- Credit counseling programs often highlight how long it takes to pay off debt at minimums but still propose solutions that take years and sacrifice retirement.
- A free consultation can reveal options you did not know existed, and saying no after learning the facts is better than never exploring them at all.
Full Transcript
Click to expand transcript
Hey, you're back with the Get Out of Debt Guy. I'm Steve Rhode, the old authentic original Get Out of Debt guy. And with me as always is Damon Day, the new Get Out of Debt guy. Damon say hello. What's up? That's good. Uh, ha ha ha ha ha ha. Always something. How many times have we heard this advice? Just look, just pay more than the damn minimum and you'll get out of debt. Now, it sounds logical. We've been through it a thousand times. We've all heard it. It sounds responsible and for someone with $5,000 in credit card debt, it's probably perfectly fine advice. But if you don't have five grand in credit card debt, you got more like 80 or more at that level, just pay more than the minimum isn't a strategy. It's, it's a slow motion disaster. And we're going to show you why today. But first, I want to jump into Damon. I've been getting back into following the news a little bit. The debt news and posting articles about it. Yeah, the old Get Out of Debt guy has been kind of resurrected as of late. I've noticed there's been more actual articles. Yeah. But you're writing. You think it's a badacle for a couple of years. Well, you know, I did. Everybody needs a break. And what I'm most interested in it in our stories that really make a difference for the average person. And so that's what I've been following. So I've been on a posting spree. But let me just cover a kind of if if anybody wants to stay in tune with what's happening on a weekday basis, then go to GetOutOfDebt.org and subscribe to the the newsletter, the email that comes out and you'll have links to all the stories. Yeah. And if you haven't been there recently, Steve recently redesigned the whole site and modernized it and it looks nice and clean and good. Not that it didn't look good before, but it looks really good. So if you haven't been there for a while, head back on over there. It's it's it's looking nice. I like it. Yeah. You know, thank you. I appreciate that because I have a massive development team that that manages the site and has a staff of one, including me. Yeah. So it's nice. It's nice to be acknowledged for all the hard work I did over Christmas. So hefty payroll. Oh, yeah. And I worked for free too. So let me just go through a couple of these stories. There is a new student loan payment plan that's coming out in July. It's called the rap plan. And you know, it's hard to get excited about student loan repayments stuff because it's it feels like we're trying to push a piece of string up a hill. Right. It's always changing. And so the best I can suggest to people is that, you know, they read the article if they have student loans and just kind of familiarize themselves. But when it comes to student loan plans, July seems like five years off. Right. Yeah. You know, everything just comes. It's going to come quick. Yeah. Probably a story that was not surprising, but it certainly concerned me was my post that I did on 24% of Americans have zero emergency savings. And that kind of gets back into what we were talking before about the K-shaped economy where, you know, half the people are doing as well or better and half the people are sinking. So those that are sinking are really, really sinking fast. Yeah. Yeah. It's it's getting it's getting tied out there, Steve. It is. And and and I know it's going to come no surprise that I'm going to say this, but a good way to keep up if you're falling behind is to get the hell out of debt. Right. Well, get rid of their debt payments. I'm not talking about even just unsecured loans. I mean, this is kind of like the new way. If you're if you're if you're struggling income wise, you know, those guys, you know, if you're only making $300,000 a year, that's become the new struggle. I feel like I feel like quarter million years, like the new struggle. I'm barely holding on. That's middle class. Yeah, it's getting crazy. But but you know, sit down and just kind of look at the money that goes because it's almost never about the money that comes in. It's almost always about how much of it is going out because you hear stories all the time of, you know, people that were teachers their whole lives and, you know, retired with over a million dollars in retirement, making, you know, for most of their careers, 50, 60,000 dollars, right? You know, so it's it's not about so much what you're making. It's about what you're able to save. Then when you start breaking it down and for for sure, credit card payments, personal loans, high interest debt, any of that stuff, we got to get rid of it. You got to get rid of that. But even, you know, the car payments, I mean, we're on the the seven year car loan. Oh, yeah. Or no big deal and 800 a month, 900 a month, a thousand dollars a month, because freaking, you know, trucks are a hundred thousand dollars. Like what? What's behind door number one, you know, a mortgage. Oh, wait, no, it's a truck, right? So like we got to also get back to that point where we're, okay, how do we get rid of these car payments? How do we keep these cars a lot longer? How we buy and use cars? I know these are not things that we can change overnight, but this, these are things that you really need to start looking at. And if you start adding up how much you're paying every month in unsecured debt and and vehicles for many of you listening, it's probably three thousand, four thousand dollars a month. It's unbelievable. And if we can just get rid of that, then you can at least survive on a quarter million dollars a year. You know, that car topic is interesting because just this weekend coming up, we're picking up a new car, but it's the first time that we've ever released a car. And let me tell you why it might not make sense for anybody else, but, but maybe me. Nobody, nobody doing gig work to make ends meet. Don't let me. No, that's true. It's, you can't do it as part of the lease, but we don't drive that many miles every year. And what I have noticed, since we've been driving Teslas, it doesn't have anything to do really with a Tesla, but the new vehicles, the new vehicles are so technology intensive, so computer intensive. Like even the Tesla that you have, Damon, you know, you look at the cameras and the computer and stuff. They feel like a dinosaur now and it's only five years old. Right. Right. And so if somebody got a six year loan or eight or whatever, there's a real concern also that that car, any car might not be supported in the future by a manufacturer, just simply because of the technology that's in it. So we're actually trading in a car that we purchased and for a lease because the car we're trading in is 21, 2021, I believe. And so the technology we can already tell it's getting behind the curve, but the lease is about $60 more a month than what the car payment was. But what I'm going to have at the end of that car payment, I'm going to have a car that is outdated technologically and is going to have significantly less value. So yeah, I agree. A lease is just renting a car. I agree. But but you're also in a different place in your life than some of our listeners are. Oh, yeah, absolutely. I'm just saying for me, for me, that made sense. You know, and I mean, Teslas are basically cell phones with wheels. Right. So so that argument makes a lot of sense because you're not going to most people aren't going to keep an iPhone for 10 years. No, it's like because the technology, it's a lot slower. It's clunkyer. Like, like I noticed major differences when I was visiting you back east of what last year. Yeah. And we went for ride in your Tesla and you put on the full self driving. Yeah, it just drove. And and and I was like, this is so much better than the full self driving in my Tesla. I understand we're talking about first world problems here. Yeah. But but but I didn't notice and I don't want to say how bad my self driving was. But compared to the self driving that Steve had, what is your Tesla 24? 24, yeah. Yeah. Compare it. Mine's a 20. His is a 24 that it's a difference in those four years. And it's it's not like I can just update the software because it's a hardware issue. He's got newer hardware, better cameras, a better computer in his car than I have in mine. So it's very it's a lot clunky or so works fine, but it's not butter smooth. Right. Like Steve's was and I left Steve's house going, do we got to buy a new test? Well, I think the cheapest lease payment on a the entry level model. Why is 479? Yeah. Well, I definitely can't lease because I between my wife and I between the gig stuff I do part time for our penny super channel to help people make more money. My wife driving the kids school and sports and all that. We put 3500 4,000 miles plus. Right. That wouldn't work for you. And if you go over the lease mileage, it's 25 cents a mile. So oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we we put 40,000 plus miles a year on that. So that Tesla, I've got 100 and almost 170,000 miles on that Tesla now. Yeah. So what I'm going to eventually do fairly quickly probably in the next, I don't know, maybe well, two years maybe I'll probably just give that one to my son. Yeah. And then I'll get a newer one. I want a 2026 and I'm going to wait till I want to be smart about it, Steve. I can get a, a, a, a, a huge 2026 and save about 15 to $20,000 on a perfectly good, still fairly new car. Right. I agree with you. Now, there's such a huge difference. Uh, one of my first vehicles was a 1969 VW bus. And Bill Cosby used to have a joke. He would say, if the fan belt breaks, use a rubber band. And he was right. I mean, there was, you know, no electronics and computers and all this other stuff. And you could actually work on it and do something. But yeah, I can't, I can't work anymore on these cars. Well, that's why a lot of people like to have the older cars and they get, because they do what they want to have a car for 10, 15 years is, you know, financially prudent as far as that they can work on. Um, that's one of the downsides. So these, it's not just Teslas, just new modern cars in general. They get so complicated and technologically advanced that they're very expensive to repair when they do break down. Yeah. And it's hard to keep them longer term because of that advanced technology. And now you've got this expensive car that's hard repair. And like you said, maybe not even supported with all the computer gizmos and technology that they have on it. So a lot of people to say, screw that. I'll take my, you know, 2005 Chevy truck and drive that to the wheels fall off. Nothing wrong with that. Absolutely not. So the last, the last story I wanted to mention was 22% of Americans believe they'll never escape credit card debt. It was a post I did this week. But here's what surprises me about that. Damon is because for listeners of the podcast, they know that almost 100% of our listeners can escape credit card debt. All they have to do is listen, follow and maybe reach out to you. Have a free conversation. They can reach you at Damonday.com, D-A-M-O-N-D-A-Y. dot com and schedule appointments, talk to Damon. All right. If you're, if you're open to strategies that don't involve just paying more than the minimum, right? And I'm not saying that strategy can't work for some of you that may work fine. But for many of you, that is not a strategy that's going to lead to success. Well, why don't you talk about the minimum payment trap with real numbers? And let's tell people how bad this can be. All right. Well, I mean, you used $80,000 bucks. Yeah. So you have $80,000 in credit cards at which I mean, my average client is over six figures in credit card debt now. So 80,000, you know, when we started doing this 20 years ago, yeah, that was a lot. $8,000 would be like, oh my gosh. That's that's how did that happen? Now it's like, no, please. Yeah. And that that was like, well, I drank too much during December. And now I got $80,000 in debt. So let's say you found yourself $80,000 in debt. Doesn't matter how you got there. Most of it is because of inflation for many of us. But let me interrupt you for a second. I just want people to understand that it doesn't matter what the number is. It's just a number. So we're not judging you by whatever the number is and you shouldn't let anyone else judge you. It's just a number. Go ahead. Yeah. So you start running through these numbers and you figure 22%. That's just the numbers that we we picked. And most people have credit cards that are higher interest in that, especially with the fed rates jumping up. A lot of you look at your statement, you might be surprised to see that you're paying over 30% yeah, interest on credit cards right now. So if you take a typical minimum payment, very low in is 2% of the balance of what you're going to pay every month. Some credit cards are 2.5, even 3%. But if we use two, that's $1,600 a month that you're paying every month for the privilege of carrying this $80,000 in debt. So if you try to pay that off paying just a minimum payments, you've all heard this before, especially if you've called a credit counseling program, they're famous for telling you how many 300 years it's going to take you to pay this off or whatever. But if you if you paid the minimums, it'll take you 25 to 30 years. In most cases, if you don't add on to it. Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, assuming you never charge that card again, but you're going to end up paying over $180,000 in that scenario. So then you say, OK, well, I'm going to eat beans and rice. I'm going to get five roommates into my house and I'm going to, you know, Dave Ramsey, my way out of this thing and everything in my life is going to be perfect. I'm never going to dip back onto it. Everything's going to be great. So instead of paying the minimum of 1,600, I'm going to throw an extra 900 bucks on that. I'm going to pay 2,500 bucks a month because I'm going to get out of this 80 grand in credit card debt. So now it's still going to take you four years. Now I would agree four years is a hell of a lot better than 25 or 30, but you're still going to end up paying $40,000 in interest. So you're going to pay 120 grand. That's better than 180. But again, this assumes everything in your life is perfect. Over the next four years, you know, the cost of food doesn't go up. Car doesn't break down. You don't have any, you know, health issues. You don't have anything happen in your life over the next four years that you don't have already planned for in your budget that you realistically can stick to over the next four years, which most people can't. Things come up life is life. So, you know, that's 120 grand. You took to pay that off and that just assumes everything is perfect. Now, can that work? Yes. That can work. If you're going to be a betting man, are you going to put all your money on that, on that working? I'm not probably not. The statistics say you're likely to fail and you don't just fail straight up. You don't just like everything's great. Everything's great. Boom. It's over. It's one of those, you know, two steps forward, one step back kind of thing or three steps back where you start doing the things you're working good, you're feeling positive and then something happens. Boom. Gotta go back on a credit card, right? And then so you do that like, eh, been flow and then two years into it, you're gone, oh my gosh, I've been killing myself. I've been doing all this stuff and I still owe 76,000 dollars. It has been two years and I've been throwing $2,500 a month at this thing. And then you start to get discouraged and then you eventually just give up, right? And that's why people carry this debt and that's why Steve's article, he just, what do you say, how many, what was the percentage of people that feel like they're never going to get out of a credit card debt? 22% 22% Well, that's why because they've probably tried multiple times and it never works out. So we have to start, you know, broadening our horizons on the options that are available and being more open-minded to trying things that are more likely to work. I am actually as you're talking calculating, you know, if you put that $2,500 into an investment, what it would be. It would be a lot more than $120,000 in debt. This would be a positive number. Uh, age, 60, and Steve's like, I expected you to talk longer. I did. I was not prepared. All right. So, uh, what did we say if you, you pay off, that's it, it'd take about $120,000 to pay off that 80 grand and four years and four years. So if instead, like you talked to Damon and you came up with an alternative plan and you didn't have to do that, that $2,500 a month, if you just put it in, uh, now you would have over almost a million dollars by the time you went to retire. Well, what, what age were you assuming? 45. If you were 45, okay, that's important to know. Yeah. Cause some guys like, well, I'm 60 now. So I'll have a million when I retire at 65. No, and isn't it surprising the number of people that call you and contact you that are nearing the end of retirement? I don't have any. Yeah. Yeah. And don't have any. Because they listened to Dave Ramsey for 30 years and just kept carrying the balances cause it never quite worked out. And they just kept carrying the balances and carrying the balances or they'd have periods where they would get out of debt, but then they go back into debt and they'll, okay, this day, Ramsey, let's do this and then they're getting 45, 50, 55, 60. We have no retirement. You know, but we got this $100,000 in credit card debt. And it's like, okay, I mean, it's never too late to start, of course, but the sooner we start to address it in a realistic way, the better. Yeah. And you can go from $80,000 credit card debt to zero within this year. There's no magic. There's no, you know, pill to take or wand away or anything else. It's just about having a realistic plan by understanding what your options are. Now, yeah. And sometimes bankruptcy is a realistic plan. It's not the only plan. I don't know. People are afraid of that, but don't be afraid of something because you haven't investigated it or you don't fully understand it. That's not a good reason to avoid something or be afraid of it. If you research it and you understand it and there's something you don't like about it, fine. Great. Now we know why we're saying no. But sometimes bankruptcy is a real solution. Sometimes it totally sucks. We have to figure out what situation you're in. Well, it's like, you know, one of the stories I posted this week was the company that owns Saks Fifth Avenue, Neiman Marcus and Bergdorf, Bergdorf, Goodman, all luxury stores, file bankruptcy and the stock market rewarded them for it because they dealt with. Yeah. So good. Men, they dealt with, you know, their financial situation instead of letting it be a investor and that is a good thing. So I mean, what did they do right? They recognized the math wasn't working. They stopped throwing good money after bad. They used legal protections for their situation and they got a fresh start to move forward. And yet, yeah, God, Damon, we see day all the time. People just keep staying in the same cesspool, expecting a different result. We need to plan. Yeah. Yeah, in business these days, they're calling it strategic de-leveraging, which is a euphemism for bankruptcy. But, you know, it sounds like we're smart, right? And they are like, okay, we can't, this is not working. Let's strategically de-leverage our balance sheet, which means get rid of the debt. And then it will look a lot nicer and we can do better moving forward. Right? I mean, things change. Life changes, circumstances change in business, same as in personal lives. Right? Sometimes you're at a point where you're just like, okay, we need to pump the brakes on this. It's not working. We need to take a page out of the business book and we're going to strategically de-leverage our personal finances and do better moving forward. Yeah, why shouldn't that be rewarded? I know. So let's talk about the high income trap. I mean, here's a cruel irony for people who make a lot of money or make good money. Whatever you want to call it, you can make those big payments. Sure. But your lifestyle is built around your income. So every month you don't pay extra, it becomes another missed opportunity. Every month you do pay extra. Well, then you end up feeling deprived and resentful. And so you don't continue doing that. I mean, the math is punishing $30,000 a year towards debt feels like sacrifice. And let's be honest, it barely moves the needle. And meanwhile, like you said, Damon, life just keeps effing happening. And soon you might do great for 21 months and then something happens. And the crack begins to form. And now you're back to where you started from. I can't tell you the number of people I've talked to over the years. Like you have said before, what's his debt from? Oh, that was from my previous consolidation. Yeah. Yeah, the last time I tried to fix it, that was carried over. Yeah. And I see that a lot with clients, especially by high earning clients. It's almost harder to make the decision when you can, what you assume you can afford the payments, right? When you're just looking on paper and how much is coming in every month? How much is going out? Okay, I have enough to cover the payments, right? But maybe there's no investments being made, no retirement savings, any of that stuff. And so it's harder to pull the trigger on a solution, especially if that solution doesn't sound fun when they're able to keep up the status quo of minimum payments, even if that's $2,000, $4,000 a month versus the clients that come to me. And they're already behind a month or two, right? And they're behind because they got to the point where it's like, I'm either going to pay my mortgage or I'm going to pay my credit card, but I can't pay both this month. Yeah, something got their attention. The mortgage, right? Now, yeah. And so now for those people, it's almost the silver lining, I would say, because the decision has already been made for them, because now they're not so much as what about my credit score? I'm already two months behind. My credit score already took a hit. Now my credit score is $5.50. Okay, well, I don't have to worry about that anymore. It's $5.50, what's done is done. How do I fix this versus somebody that's been paying $3,000 a month, keeping the minimum payments, keeping the creditors happy, keeping the credit bureaus patting them on the back saying, you're doing such a good job. Keep going. You know, they're like, oh, I got a 740 credit score. And I've always had a 740 credit score. And I don't want to hurt that. So I, you know, missing a couple of payments so I can negotiate a better deal on these credit cards doesn't sound good or filing bankruptcy doesn't sound good. That's going to hurt my credit. Now, it lives too expensive without a good credit score. It's like, hell, life's costing you $36,000 a year right now with a great credit score. Yeah, that's what you're paying for it. Sounds to me like a good credit score is just keeping you in debt is very expensive. You know, Bergedorf, Neiman Marcus and Sax with Avenue, I think in that story, if I remember correctly, they had over 25,000 creditors. Yeah. That's what you mentioned yesterday when we recorded this podcast the first time for the first time. This is our second time through on this podcast. It didn't work yesterday. That's why it's late this week. And this is so much better than yesterday's. We did a trial run. Maybe we should start doing a practice run every week. Yeah. I just got a PTSD because I looked at the time. It was right about now the whole thing crapped out. All right. Let's talk about what the credit card companies love and what they love are people who pay the minimum payment every month. They don't care if you can afford it or not. They're just look and you're only good as your last payment. We've talked before about, you know, the person that was so afraid to miss a payment day, man, that they just kept spending down the money that they had. And then when that was gone, guess what? They missed a payment. Yeah. Well, when the circumstances force you to miss, it's almost like an easier choice versus when you're seeing they're going, well, technically I could pay, but I have to pull that $1,000 out of my savings account or I have to pull that $1,000 from my retirement. This one kills me. Do not pull money from the retirement until you know exactly what you're doing and have a plan for that. Yeah. That's a plan. It's so much better when you call me, when you have a whole bunch of money in your retirement that you haven't tapped into yet. We have so many other options. Even if that option might even be bankruptcy, that money is protected. But unfortunately, a lot of clients, they, they don't find us or reach out until they've tried everything that they think is right or they have available and they've got no savings and no retirement. And it's like, yeah, I've been pulling down from my 401K for the last four years, you know, hoping this was going to get better. Consolidate trying to figure this out. And now all they've done was drain, you know, 150 grand out of their 401K. And we still have debt to deal with and now tax issues to deal with because they, they took the money out of 401K, cause the tax issue and now they're even behind on that. So don't make any drastic moves without calling me first. I know that's a shameless plug, but it's good advice. It's still good advice. It's a serving or not. It's still good advice. Just call me first. Let's talk it through before you do anything drastic. Well, it's because nobody wants to admit this or say it to themselves and nobody's going to say it to you. But you know that your situation may be beyond what will power alone can solve. Yeah. Yeah. A willing, a better budget or willing more money or willing more door dash orders you can fill is not a solution because at high debt levels, what you need more is a different strategy, not more effort. Yeah. I'm trying harder at the wrong approach. Just burns you out faster. Takes your money faster. I know. I think about, I mean, I've been there too in my life. But you know, you're doing whatever you can each month just trying to get by. And at some point, like enough is enough. How, why did I just waste that last year? Well, I share the story quite often, but I know the way our podcast works, a lot of our listeners just kind of stumble upon us and their new listeners. But the story I tell about that client I had that called me and, you know, we went through all the stuff and she had good income and a lot of debt. It was over a quarter million dollars. And she just couldn't get past that idea of needing to be behind and taking the hit to her credit score because what, wait, since was to negotiate that debt, I mean, she was in a situation where she was not going to be able to pay it off. Right. And you know, we had that talk and then I, I never heard from her again. We did that one consult and I never heard from her. She just, she told me she's, I'm not ready to do that. So, okay, no problem. And I didn't hear from her for 10 years. Literally 10 years out of the blue. I got an email one day. Hey, we talked 10 years ago. I went back and pulled up my, my, my records and sure enough, there she was. That all my notes from the conversation 10 years ago. And this was now about five years ago. This happened, you know, so the original conversation was 15 years ago. And, and she called me up and said, Hey, you know, I think you were right. I'm ready to listen now. So we got back on the phone again. I, and the only thing that had changed in her life after a decade was she was another $100,000 deeper in the whole. And she'd been, she'd kept that debt current for a decade. She spent over a million dollars just trying to, you know, not ding her credit score and trying to pay that off in a traditional Dave Ramsey-esque way. And she finally just had, you know, everybody's got their own pace and their own timing. And it took her 10 years before she was like, Okay, you know what? I'm willing to buy the bullet. And she ended up hiring me. We had her completely out of debt in less than 18 months. All of that debt gone negotiated done behind her. She even had a, a delinquent second mortgage back from the 08 crash on, on, on a house that she hadn't been in in 10 years. We were able to get that settle too. So she went from carrying that debt for a decade with all the interest included to we did 10 years later. What I suggested we do 10 years previous. Yeah. And we were done in 18 months. You could have had all that debt done a decade soon. So it was all that was, you know, and that's okay. Eight and a half years of wasted effort. But she needed to do that in order to be mentally ready to have a plan. Yeah. So my big thing is just know what you're saying. Yes, to know what you're saying. No, to don't think about Oh, Bank of C. That's big scary thing. And I heard this from my aunt, those brothers, you know, sister's mother. They tried that and that did this or whatever it is. Get good solid information. Figure out how it applies specifically to your situation and then make a decision about whether it's a good strategy for you or not. I mean, let's use that example that we used earlier. You know, let's say you're making good money and you're not at the penny stage in your budget. But one of the things you can do is you can actually strategically default. If you know what you're doing and you understand what it is and you know what the consequences are and you have a plan. So instead of spending that $2,500 a month forever, at least for the next 30 years, while you're trying to limp along pay off this thing, you could actually stop making them in my payments, put it into a settlement fund and you will have enough money accumulated that like Damon said, you could actually settle that debt if you knew what the best deals were. And you could resolve it without bankruptcy. Yeah. Yeah. And there's pros and cons of that strategy. Same thing. Don't jump into it without no one who's packing your parachute. Right. Like make sure you understand what you're doing before you. I we're not saying, Hey, I listened to these guys on the podcast and I just stop paying my debts because they said to not saying blindly going blindly, just stop paying without knowing specifically why and specifically what would happen if you don't make a payment. Right. I don't I don't make the rules. The credit card companies make up the rules. So, you know, this is their game. We're just winning at it. Right. That's right. Right. I mean, sir, there are tradeoffs, no matter what you do, if you're dealing with getting rid of your debt now to do better financially moving forward, you might have a temporary credit report hit. You might have some additional stress during the process. But actually, both of those things are so easy to deal with if you have the knowledge about what reality is instead of assuming and having fear. When you understand how the game is played, it's like, Oh, child, no, we don't need to worry about that. And when you're in debt, there's always going to be stress. Even if you keep doing what you're doing, that's stressful. That's probably why you're listening to this podcast because you're feeling stressed about having the debt and having to make the payments. So, yeah, if you filed the bankruptcy, there's going to be some stress involved there, depending on, you know, how you feel about it, settlement, any any kind of solution, you know, not not making a payment, that's going to involve stress. But everything is going to involve stress. So it's just a matter of understanding what makes the most sense and and and moving forward in what's the best way to describe it. Moving forward in awareness. Rather than blind faith. Yeah. And if you've all of a sudden you heard what we said and you think I need to contact some debt settlement companies back the bus up because they want to sell you one thing. And so if if I have inadequately, can they use a very expensive? Yeah. And if I have not done a good job conveying, the issue is not don't pick the solution to get out of debt first. You need to have some guidance and wisdom and advice to pick the right solution based on your situation because everybody is different. Yeah. And knowing the right solution fixes the stress part. Yeah. You know, understanding what you're doing and why you're doing it goes a long way to alleviate any stress. Well, especially if they already know, you know what? You might get some collection notices. It's like, all right. Put it in the box. I want to get a collection notice. Fine. Well, you're going to get a bill just keep paying the bill. Yeah. Well, I can't afford to pay the bill. Okay. All right. Well, if you can't afford to pay it, we got it. We got to pick your poison here. Yeah. So there's no magic wand. There's a path. Yeah. There's no magic wand. Exactly. All right. So last week we gave people homework and we told them to do the hard work of the January audit. You know, find out what your real numbers are, write them down, figure out what you actually owe and pay. And then it'll we showed you why those numbers require a different approach than just whatever stuff Dave Ramsey is selling about budgeting and eating beans and rice to get out of debt. So this podcast is for people who really want to do better, want to find happiness, recognize that financial problems have nothing to do with personal failure. Your, your, you know, value as a person or anything else. It's just math wrapped in emotion. And if you're drowning, we want to show you exactly why conventional advice fails you. So what are we doing next Thursday, Steve? I were going to flip the script, I think. Yeah, I thought you were doing that. Well, next Thursday. Oh, shit, I got to edit something now. Why leave it in? Like us. So next Thursday, we're going to show you why your income is actually your biggest asset in getting out of debt. Your income is not the problem. It's the solution. And we're going to show you how it's going to change how you see your situation. Yeah. So if this episode made you feel seen, if you've tried to pay more than the minimum and watch the balance barely move, you need what's coming next. Subscribe so you don't miss it. This week is what I want you to do. I want you to run the numbers on your own debt. Go to a compound interest calculator. There's a ton of free ones out there. Just Google it, chat GPT, it, whatever you want. Yeah. Plug in the total debt you have. Your interest rates, the various payment amounts. See how long it takes. Let the math speak for itself. So you're not failing at debt payoff because you lack discipline. You're failing because you're using the wrong tool for the job. So Damon, next week, let's talk about finding the right tool. And I will see you. Peace.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does paying more than the minimum fail at high debt levels?
When you owe $80,000 or more, a huge portion of every payment goes to interest charges. Even paying significantly above the minimum barely moves the principal balance. At these levels, you could pay for decades and still owe a substantial amount.
What percentage of Americans think they will never get out of debt?
According to recent data, 22% of Americans believe they will never escape credit card debt. This often happens because they have tried conventional advice like paying more than minimums multiple times without success.
Is bankruptcy really an option for credit card debt?
Yes. Bankruptcy is a legal tool designed to give people a fresh start. Major corporations use it regularly. For individuals with $80K or more in unsecured debt, Chapter 7 bankruptcy can eliminate the debt entirely while protecting retirement accounts.
How much does high debt cost in retirement savings?
Many people with high debt spend $3,000 to $4,000 per month on minimum payments for unsecured debt and vehicles. That money invested over the same period could grow to $400,000 or more in retirement savings, making the true cost far greater than the debt itself.
Should I talk to someone before making a decision about my debt?
Yes. Steve and Damon recommend getting a free consultation to understand all your options before committing to any strategy. Damon is co-host of the Get Out of Debt Guy podcast, and Steve receives no payment for this referral. You can always say no after learning the facts, but you cannot make a good decision without complete information.