The Number Was Never Built to Measure You
I have watched people do genuinely destructive things to their own lives to protect a three-digit number, and almost none of them could tell me what the number actually measures.
So let me tell you, because it matters more than anything else in this post.
Credit scoring was built to solve a lender’s problem, not yours. Before it existed, a loan officer sat across a desk and made a judgment call, one person at a time, slowly and inconsistently. Scoring automated that. It let a bank sort millions of applicants by how likely they were to produce a profitable, repaid loan. That is the job it was designed for, and it does that job extremely well.
What it was never designed to do is tell you whether you are doing all right.
Each weekday I send one short email: one story that caught my attention, why it might matter to you, and one manageable thing you can do with it. A couple of minutes, and a dad joke.
In the latest issue (Nov 9): Check your power bank and your French press
Free. I sell nothing. Unsubscribe any time.
A FICO score is a sucker number. It measures how much profit you can be counted on to make for a lender.
There is no meaningful connection between how well you manage your money and what that number says. You can have an 830 and be one transmission away from disaster. You can have a 560 and a paid-off house. The score does not know about your savings, your income, your emergency fund, or whether you sleep at night. It cannot see any of it.
On this week’s show, my co-host Damon Day launched a campaign around this idea with a name blunt enough that I am not going to print it in full. The polite version is forget the FICO. The real version has more teeth, and having watched what fear of that number does to people for three decades, I understand exactly why he chose it.
Fear the Right Thing
Neither of us is telling you credit does not matter. It plainly does. Life is easier with a good score, and if your income depends on borrowing — you flip houses, you run a business on a credit line — that changes the math entirely and you should say so out loud when you are weighing options.
The problem is narrower and much more common than that. It is when the score becomes the reason someone makes a decision that damages them.
I have watched people drain retirement accounts, empty savings, and borrow from family to keep a number intact. Here is the question almost nobody asks themselves before doing it:
Would you take a temporarily lower score for a year in exchange for tens of thousands of dollars still sitting in your retirement account?
Because that is frequently the actual trade, stated honestly. Nobody puts it that way, so it never gets weighed that way.
You will not reach the end of your life grateful that your score was 850. You may very well reach it wishing you had money. Those are the two outcomes competing, and only one of them is real.
Kids can inherit your money. They cannot inherit your FICO.
That Credit Line Is Not Yours
This is the part of the episode I most want people to sit with, because it is the mechanical reason the fear backfires.
Whatever card is in your wallet right now, you do not own that credit line. You have the use of it, at the lender’s discretion, for exactly as long as the lender finds it profitable. It is not an asset. It is a permission slip, and it can be revoked without notice, without your having done anything wrong.
Jamie Dimon has been warning publicly about a credit-led recession — a downturn that starts not with layoffs but with lenders getting nervous and pulling back. When that happens, the first thing lenders do is reduce risk. They cut limits. They close inactive accounts. They tighten standards.
Now follow what that does to someone who has been carefully protecting their score:
- You owe $20,000 against $40,000 in limits. Your utilization is 50%.
- The lender cuts your limits to $25,000. You did nothing. You were never late.
- Your utilization is now 80%, and your score falls.
You had no control over any of it. You spent years protecting a number that a risk committee could move against you in an afternoon. That is the whole argument in one paragraph.
Available Credit Is Not an Emergency Fund
Here is the version of this that does the most damage, and I see it constantly.
Somebody is doing everything they were told to do. Throwing every spare dollar at the debt. Paycheck to paycheck, no savings, but they are not worried, because they still have available credit. That is the transmission money. That is the emergency money.
Then the limits get cut.
Now there is no available credit and no cash, because it all went to the balance. One unbudgeted problem and the whole thing collapses — and it collapses precisely because they were doing what looked like the responsible thing.
A cushion you cannot lose beats a cushion someone else controls. That is why I tell people to keep three months of expenses in actual money even while they are paying down debt. It is not the mathematically optimal answer on a spreadsheet. It is the answer that survives contact with reality.
Why Everyone Looks Richer Than You
One more thing worth knowing, because it makes people feel like they are failing when they are not.
You go out on a Friday night. The restaurants are packed. The parking lot is full of new cars. Everything is expensive and yet everyone appears to be able to afford it, and you sit there with your debt thinking you are the only one who cannot keep up.
You are not looking at wealth. You are looking at credit.
A great deal of what appears to be prosperity is available limits being spent. That is also why a credit-led downturn moves as fast as it does — when the limits shrink, the spending stops almost immediately, and then the layoffs follow the spending rather than causing it.
What Actually Happens to Your Score After
Damon’s position, and mine, comes down to one sentence that most people find hard to believe:
Your FICO will bounce back faster than you could have paid off the debt the traditional way, in almost every scenario.
— Damon Day
Sit with the comparison, because it is the one that never gets made. The choice is not “damaged credit” versus “good credit.” It is a shorter period of damaged credit against several more years of carrying the debt — during which the score is being dragged down by the balances anyway.
People imagine a decade in the wilderness. What actually happens is bumpier and much shorter than that, and the hurdles that do come up tend to be solvable. Turned down by one institution and approved across the street by another, with the same report and the same income. That happens routinely, because different lenders have entirely different policies, and one lender’s no is not the market’s answer.
I am not telling you to file bankruptcy or to settle. I am telling you that refusing to even look at an option because of what it does to a number is not a decision. It is a reflex.
Settlement Got Harder, and Nobody Updated the Advice
We spent part of the show on something that has genuinely changed, and the advice circulating online has not caught up.
The old model went like this: let it charge off, wait, a debt buyer purchases the account for pennies, and eventually settles cheap because anything beats nothing. People still repeat that on forums as though it were a law of nature.
What Damon is seeing now, and what I am hearing too, is different:
- Debt buyers are moving to litigation faster. Filing suit is cheap. Most people who get sued never file an answer, so the case ends in a default judgment — which is a far better outcome for the buyer than negotiating.
- Waiting can cost you money instead of saving it. Turning down a deal in the hope of a better one later is a real gamble now. Once a lawsuit is filed, you can still negotiate, but you are negotiating from a much worse position.
- The original creditor is often the better deal. This reverses the conventional wisdom entirely. If you can find the funds, settling before charge-off is frequently better than what waits on the other side.
- Some states are far more litigious than others. The same debt behaves differently depending on where you live, which is why generic internet advice is worth roughly what you paid for it.
Terms Matter as Much as the Percentage
The other mistake I see is people judging an offer purely on the discount and ignoring what it costs to get there.
Say you owe $10,000 at 25% interest. Somebody offers to settle at 75 cents on the dollar, and the reflex is to refuse — only a 25% discount, not worth it. But if that $7,500 is payable over four years at no interest, compare it to what you were actually on track to pay. Carrying $10,000 at 25% for years does not cost you $10,000. It costs you considerably more, and the interest you stop paying is real money that never shows up in the discount percentage.
Run the total, not the headline. A smaller discount with good terms routinely beats a bigger discount with bad ones.
If You Had a Second Mortgage in 2008, Read This
One warning worth its own line. A lot of people came out of the housing crisis assuming a second mortgage simply evaporated. Nobody called for years, so it must be gone.
It is not necessarily gone. Those loans have been bought up, and because a second mortgage carries a lien against the property, the holder does not have to sue you the way an unsecured creditor does. They can move directly toward foreclosure on a debt you had written off mentally a decade ago.
If that describes you, find out where that loan stands now, on your own timeline, rather than finding out from a notice.
The Payment App Cash Advance Trap — and the Part the Show Got Backwards
This one happened to me, which is the only reason I found it.
I had some pressure washing done. The contractor would only take payment through a peer-to-peer app. I do not like linking my checking account to outside services, so I funded the payment with a credit card. The statement came and there was a cash advance fee on it.
Here is the mechanism, and it is worth understanding before it happens to you. When you fund a peer-to-peer payment with a credit card, your card issuer may classify it as a cash advance rather than a purchase. That is not the app’s decision — it is your issuer’s. And a cash advance is a different animal from a purchase in three ways at once:
- A fee, typically a percentage of the amount, charged immediately.
- A higher interest rate than your purchase rate.
- No grace period. Interest starts the day of the transaction. There is no paying it off before the due date to avoid the charge.
Issuers differ on this, and the answer for your specific card is in your cardholder agreement, not in a blog post. Look up “cash advance” in it before you fund anything that way.
Now the correction, because I would rather be right than consistent
On the show we said that once you take a cash advance, you cannot pay it off until you have paid off your entire regular balance first. I went and checked the actual rule afterward, and that is not quite how it works — and the accurate version is genuinely more useful.
Federal law, in Regulation Z § 1026.53, says this about anything you pay above your minimum:
“the card issuer must allocate the excess amount first to the balance with the highest annual percentage rate and any remaining portion to the other balances in descending order based on the applicable annual percentage rate.”
So money paid above the minimum has to go at your highest-rate balance first — which is usually the cash advance. That is the law working in your favor.
But the same regulation’s official commentary is explicit that it “does not limit or otherwise address the card issuer’s ability to determine” how the minimum payment itself is allocated. The issuer may apply your minimum wherever it likes, including to the lowest-rate balance.
Put those two halves together and you get the actual rule to live by:
Pay only the minimum, and a high-rate cash advance can sit there accruing interest indefinitely. Pay meaningfully above the minimum, and the law requires that extra money to attack the cash advance first.
The trap is real. It is just built out of the minimum payment rather than out of the whole balance — and that distinction is the difference between being stuck and getting out.
What I Would Do This Week
1. Write down what your score is actually protecting
Not “good credit” in the abstract. The specific thing you need it for, and when. Buying a house in eighteen months is an answer. “In case” is not, and “in case” is what most people are really defending.
2. Count your cash, not your limits
Add up what you could put your hands on this week without borrowing. If the honest answer is close to nothing but you feel covered because of available credit, you have found the exposure. Fix that before you optimize anything else.
3. Check your cardholder agreement for “cash advance”
Ten minutes, once, and you will know what your card does with a peer-to-peer payment before it costs you rather than after.
4. If you are considering settlement, look at every option first
Including the ones with bad public relations. Compare total cost and total time, not discount percentages. And do not let a strategy from a decade-old forum post drive a decision you are making today.
What I Actually Want for You
I do not want you frightened. Fear is what makes people reach for whatever promises to stop the feeling fastest, and that is exactly how bad decisions get made at three in the morning.
I want you to have information and to make an educated choice, whichever one it turns out to be. Sometimes protecting your credit is the right call and there is a way to solve the debt without hurting it at all. Sometimes it is not. The only way to know is to look at everything honestly, including the options you were taught not to look at.
Damon Day and I release a new episode weekly. You can reach him directly through damonday.com. Damon is my podcast co-host, and I receive no payment for this referral. And if you want to think out loud with somebody first, ask me. It is free, it is private, and I sell nothing.
If this was useful, send it to the one person you know who is protecting a number instead of protecting themselves.
This is my input, not instruction. Your situation has details I cannot see from here, and a decision this size deserves someone looking at your actual numbers.
Dealing With Debt? Understanding your options is the first step. See how all your debt relief options compare — including ones most sites won’t tell you about. The Find Your Path quiz gives a recommendation based on your actual numbers, and the Scam-O-Meter checks any company’s complaint history before you sign. Federal Reserve Bank of New York research shows bankruptcy filers recover faster than those who don’t file.
Key Takeaways
- A credit score measures how profitable you are likely to be to a lender. It was never built to tell you whether you are managing your money well.
- The credit line in your wallet is not yours. A lender can cut it without notice, which spikes your utilization and drops your score through no fault of your own.
- Available credit is not an emergency fund. A cushion nobody can revoke beats a bigger one somebody else controls.
- Much of the spending that makes everyone else look richer than you is credit, not wealth. That is why a credit-led downturn moves so fast.
- Your score recovers faster than you would have paid the debt off the traditional way, so the real comparison is a short credit hit against several more years of carrying balances.
- Debt settlement got harder. Buyers now move to litigation quickly, and settling with the original creditor before charge-off is frequently the better deal.
- Judge a settlement on total cost and terms, not the discount. A 25% discount at zero interest can beat a larger discount that still carries interest.
- Funding a peer-to-peer payment with a credit card may be coded as a cash advance: a fee, a higher rate, and no grace period. Pay above the minimum, because federal law only sends the excess at your highest-rate balance.
Full Transcript
Click to expand transcript
Full transcript of the April 30, 2026 episode with Steve Rhode and Damon Day. Lightly cleaned for readability; the substance is unchanged.
Opening: Bankers Are Warning About the Economy
Back to the Get Out of Debt Guy show. I'm the old Get Out of Debt Guy, Steve Rhode, and with me as always is the new, fresher-smelling Get Out of Debt Guy, Damon Day. Say hello, Damon. I am certainly fresher. Yes, you are.
And if you want to talk to Damon in person, you know, you can always reach out and touch his ear, at least, at damonday.com, D-A-M-O-N-D-A-Y dot com. So, Damon, it has been a hell of a week financially. I think what's very interesting is, you know, I was talking to somebody the other day, and you look at the cost of gas, and there's no end in sight for when those prices are going to come down, and they're leaking out in other parts of the economy. And, you know, somebody said to me, God, things are really tight, and I don't know what to do. And I said, Well, you know, fuel prices went up, and you're driving a diesel truck, and it's killing you.
And their response was, Well, you know, sometimes you just got to take some pain. That's just not a plan. Well, you know, I mean, I took my daughter—again, I think I told a similar story, but it happens every day. It's like Groundhog Day for me. My wife's gone out of state with my son, who's at a baseball tournament in Texas, and so I'm doing the Mr.
Mom kind of thing, which I'm not used to having to do with my other two kids. So I'm driving my daughter to school, and I remember just getting in the Tesla this morning and waving to my diesel truck. That sucker just sits in the driveway right now. I mean, I'm like, why would I not drive the Tesla? It's crazy.
I was watching a video on Facebook or something, Jeff Dunham, you know, the comedian, the puppet guy. I like Jeff Dunham. He's a funny guy. He was doing a little thing filling up his truck at a gas station in California. It was a—he had a 250, an F-250 diesel truck.
And it was $223. It was $7.49 to fill up per gallon in diesel. Yeah, in California. And it was $223, and I'm just like, I zipped my Tesla around for two or three bucks for what somebody with the F-250 in California is paying $220 to take them the same miles. I was telling the story at lunch today about sitting at a red light, and the light changes, and next to me is a diesel pickup truck all jacked up and everything.
And I'm driving my Tesla, and the pickup truck decides it just wants to, you know, roll coal and smoke me. You're like, That cost 50 bucks, bro. You realize all that smoke is money pouring out your tailpipe. So I got to the next light, and we're still side by side, and the light changed, and I hit it and went zero to 60 in four seconds and made no noise. I would have stayed with them as long as you could and tried to just keep them rolling coal every light and just laughing your ass off every time.
That cost that guy $100 for being stupid. That's a stupid tax. It always makes me say to myself, you know, you do you, boo. I mean, what are you trying— Just turn on your air recirculator and laugh the whole time. That's right.
You know, we have the hazmat filter, whatever it's called. Yeah, you can just filter out all that stuff. But, you know, if you want to throw your money away trying to send me some message, go for it. I don't care. And dude, I love my diesel truck as well as the next guy, and if I'm pulling the trailer somewhere, I'll just do it, right?
But if I'm just chilling by myself in my truck, I got to go grab some groceries or drop off my kid or whatever. I love driving my truck, but I love driving the Tesla more when it's three dollars. Yeah, I think, you know, I remember. Don't you remember when diesel fuel was cheaper than gas? Yeah, and you know when it switched, right?
When diesel started becoming more expensive than gas? When I bought a diesel truck. That's the exact moment in time that it switched. We jumped the shark because I decided, I'm gonna be smart. I'm gonna buy a diesel truck.
It's cheaper. I don't remember exactly why it happened. It must be something. Well, there's some excuse behind it, that's for sure. Oh, I know what happened, because diesel trucks became popular and more people started buying them.
I feel really bad right now for all the farmers and truckers that are just getting, you know, slaughtered with these prices. I don't know how they're gonna make it. Yeah, 100%. And as we're talking, I think I'm on my wrong speaker. Hold on.
Your wrong speaker. You are on your wrong— My microphone. Microphone, I can tell because your headset is fuzzy. How'd that be? That be better?
Well, you should have told me before we started, Steve. Well, you know, I wanted to maintain the high production value and not go, Hey, dumbass! Yeah. But there you are. We gotta make sure the people get what they pay for here.
Another—I liked it when, for my online newspaper that I had, somebody would go, Well, I don't like what you said. I'm gonna unsubscribe from the free newspaper. You go right ahead. Why are you reading it if you don't like it? Yeah.
All right, so we're talking about money, credit, and debt. Everybody is living through a slow burn. Damon told me which articles he picked out for the show today, and one of them is about Jamie Dimon, you know, the very popular, well-respected banker. But not to be confused with Dustin Diamond. No, he's the very well-respected wanker.
But what? How long did you spend in England? That is screech. Oh, he was arrested for public masturbation in an adult theater. Oh, so him and Pee-wee share a special place, huh?
Yeah. And, well, Dustin was doing adult… Steve, that's—I don't know where you go in the dark corners at night on the interwebs, but I have no idea about that. And I believe both of them have actually passed, I believe. Both Pee-wee and Screech.
I don't think they're with us anymore. Well… Yeah, he was—on that note. Oh, yeah, and then he was—he stabbed somebody. Yeah, so, okay.
I don't know how that turned to that, but back to Jamie Dimon. You took us there. That wasn't… So Jamie Dimon, you know, this is every week we see these tea leaves of people who manage money or finances or something providing warnings about the economy. And I think we're at a very kind of interesting time right now because while the unemployment rate is relatively low, The rate of people changing jobs or moving up or finding better jobs is very low.
I don't think there's a rash of people out there right now who are quitting their jobs feeling very confident they're going to get a better position. And then you've got Jamie Dimon and other bankers that are talking about the fact that, you know, we're probably heading for a recession. And so, as we have talked about in weeks past, I absolutely don't want to be Chicken Little. You know, it's time to ditch your debt and get ready for less friendly times. Yeah.
And it's time to, you know, really focus on what's important. And, you know, I called Steve today. I was going to spring it on him just on the call, but I thought, no, maybe I'll let him get ready for it first. But I'm rolling out a new thing. I'm getting a little bit frustrated, I think.
You know, it's about this FICO score, Steve, and just how attached so many people are to this FICO score and how many just bad financial decisions are made every day because of this fear of the FICO, right? Fear of the FICO. Is that what you're going to call it? No, I could call it that. Chicken shit out of it.
I don't want to call it fear. No, I'm not calling it fear of the FICO. What are you going to call it? So I've thought about it, and I was like, I don't want to do that, but you know what? Damn it, we're calling it Fuck the FICO.
I like that. Fuck the FICO. And the reason we're calling it that, I thought, you don't really need to, you know, be that vulgar with it, but I think it's catchy. And I'm just so tired of people putting themselves and their families in bad spots all because they're so afraid of this mystical FICO score and doing something that FICO wouldn't like. The millions and millions of dollars that people have wasted, the retirement accounts gutted because they feared the FICO rather than saying, Fuck the FICO, right?
Do not fear the FICO. Fuck the FICO. You know, people think that your FICO score is some indication about how well you're doing financially or managing your bills or your money or something. It's not. Believe me, it is.
There is no connection in reality about how well you manage your personal finances and your FICO score. You can have a fabulous FICO score and drowning in other parts of your life and setting up a terrible situation that's going to explode in your life. And the FICO—let's get back to what the FICO score actually does before you want to F it, because
What a FICO Score Actually Measures
the FICO score was designed as a way to make lending more automated and easier so that there could be an algorithm that determined what somebody's individual consumer risk was to the bankers. So really, the FICO score is nothing but a sucker number about how much profit you can make for the bankers. Yeah, and I'm not going all
When the FICO Becomes a Hindrance
Dave Ramsey, because Dave Ramsey's whole shtick is basically you don't even need it. You don't need credit cards. You don't need any of that stuff. I'm not saying, and Steve's not saying, it's not easier to operate within society with a good FICO score. It 100% is.
It absolutely is. That's not what we're saying. But what I get peeved about is when the FICO score is a hindrance to somebody making the right financial choice, right? It's when it's causing them to make bad choices for the sole reason of, I fear the FICO. I fear the change to the FICO.
I fear the unknown of what would my life look like if I couldn't borrow more money for a few years. Well, hell, what would your life look like if you didn't owe $100,000 right now? Yeah, would you be willing to take a FICO score that was 150 points lower for the next nine months and be able to have an additional $100,000 in retirement? Yeah, it's like you got to start, you know, fear the right thing. Fear being broke off your ass when you're 80 years old.
Fear that. That sucks. You know, who gives a shit about your FICO score in the short term? When you're 80 years old, you know, you're not going to, like, look back and admonish your 60-year-old self for having bad credit for a couple of years, but now you've got money to retire on, right? Now, versus if you're 80 years old and broke off your ass, you're going to be really pissed at your 60-year-old self for not making a better choice, and you're not going to give a crap what your FICO score was 20 years ago.
So if you're worried, the thing I see people doing all the time for the last three or four decades is spending down assets that they have because they're afraid of, What's it going to do to my credit score? And the reality is, if you're sitting on the side of the table where Damon and I are, the real answer to that question is, Who the fuck cares? Yeah. Yeah, and I, you know, it's a very valid question. I'm not, you know, invalidating your feelings on, you know, how hard my life is going to be if my credit's not good, because that's something we can definitely discuss and talk about.
But when people look at, you know, the value in the FICO score versus the value in cash in the bank, especially in the short term, again, I'm not arguing, you know, don't ever get credit cards again and don't ever have credit. I'm not saying that. I'm just saying if you're in a spot… Where a good FICO score got you into a bad spot or helped you get into a bad spot, maybe it's not that big a deal to not have good credit for a couple of years so we can get out of the bad spot and stop feeling like you are, you know, you need to have available credit in case there's an emergency. How about you need to have cash in case there's an emergency?
Stop relying so much on, I got to have this good credit score, especially if you're at a point where nobody's willing to loan you any more money anyway because you got too much debt.
Your Credit Line Is Not Yours
That falls right into this article that I put out on getoutofdebt.org, the one Jamie Dimon just warned about a credit recession. And this falls right into what you just said, because banks get skittish about the economy, and what is the first thing they do? They start clawing back credit limits and access to credit. And so if you're worried about your FICO score and you're not paying down your debt, you're getting rid of that, you could actually get yourself in a worse situation when your utilization rate goes way up because your credit limit just got reduced and you have no control and authority over that. Here's something that Damon and I have seen all these decades, which is somebody will say, I'm going to use American Express as an example.
I have been a loyal American Express cardholder for the last 25 years, and I have made all my payments, and they closed my account or they reduced my balance or something, and I'm pissed off because I like having this card. It's not your card. Whatever bank card you have in your wallet right now, You have the luxury of enjoying using it and taking advantage of it. It's not yours. And a lot of you listening to this probably have already experienced this recently, where you've had credit lines cut, even though you've never been late, and you've had lines of credit cut for what you perceive to be no good reason, right?
And that's tying into what Jamie Dimon is talking about, where creditors are getting skittish. So if you're in a situation where you don't have cash, and even if you are paying down your debt slowly, right, and you're doing good, and, you know, I'm doing my Dave Ramsey thing and I'm paying it down, and it's great, but I don't really have any savings. I don't really have any cash. I'm paycheck to paycheck, but that's okay because I've got $20,000 in available credit still. I owe 100 grand, but I'm throwing $3,000 a month, $4,000 a month at this 100 grand.
It's slowly starting to pay down. I've got 20 grand in available credit. That's my emergency money. That's my, I need a new transmission money. That's my, oh, I got to go on this plane trip, or whatever it is.
I don't need the savings because I got the credit cards. And then good old Jamie Dimon comes along and goes, Eh, we're lowering our risk profile a little bit here. Just, dear John letter, dear Jane letter, just to let you know, it's nothing you did. It's not you. It's us.
We're just going to make some changes, and we're going to take away that $20,000 in available credit. So now you're at a spot where you've got no available credit for emergencies, and you've got no extra cash because you've been throwing it all on trying to do, air quotes, the right thing and pay down all your debts. And now you're in a spot where one little bump in the road that's not budgeted for and you're screwed. You got no credit and you got no cash, and you did it to yourself because you feared the FICO.
Fear the Right Thing
I want to go back to your air quotes. What is the right thing? Right? That's the thing that always gets everybody. I want to do the right thing.
But what is that? I mean, the right thing for who? That's why I put it in air quotes, because it's ambiguous. I mean, I'm going to what? I'm going to sacrifice my future and ability to have a roof over my head so I don't piss off Chase Bank?
Well, ask yourself this. Rephrase: what the right thing for you or the right thing for the bank? Which right thing do you care about? The right thing for your kids or the right thing for Jamie Dimon? Yeah, I'm going to do the right thing for the bank, and I'm going to make all these payments and drain my account because I've been such a loyal customer and they've been so good to me.
Yeah, that's fine. That's one approach. We all make our choices. Yeah. And again, we're not saying that's wrong, right?
Every situation is different. All I'm saying is, you know, fearing the FICO score and having the FICO score should not be your, you know, your most… Important thing, that shouldn't be above all else, unless your income heavily relies on the FICO and, like, you would lose your business, right? If your business was flipping houses and you needed that FICO to get new funding, if you didn't get new funding, you wouldn't be able to generate any income. Okay, well, let's talk about that.
That's a different scenario. You'd be cutting off your nose maybe to spite your face. But for most of us, where your income doesn't rely on having that good FICO, you know, having to put off buying a new car for an extra year or something like that. Or people, I get people that, Well, I want to be able to buy a new house. Okay, fine, I get it.
What's the timeline? Well, I'd like to be able to buy a new house in the next 12 to 24 months. Okay, well, right now I'm looking at your situation. I don't care if your FICO is 850. You got so much debt, you can't afford what you have now, much less a new mortgage.
So, you know, the FICO is just one aspect of it. So many people are worried about that FICO score, not even understanding that their overall finances are not even at a point that would allow them to do the thing that they're wanting to do, which is why they're afraid to hit their FICO. So it's just a matter of looking at your overall situation, and sometimes the best way out is through. Sometimes it's okay to say, You know what? Let's just, let's go hog right now, or go ham, or whatever you want to say, and let's just get rid of all this debt so we can get ourselves in a point where we've got cash in the bank, we can sleep at night, we're not worried about the stupid FICO thing.
Sometimes that's a good option, whether it's a bankruptcy, a settlement, or whatever it is. Sometimes getting out of the debt—oftentimes, actually—getting out of the debt and getting some cash in the bank is way more important for you and your family than what the stupid FICO number is. I agree with what you said earlier. I hope—I absolutely can guarantee. I am not going to be on my deathbed, and my last thought as I fall off into a long slumber is, Thank God my FICO score was 850.
Yeah. Yeah, you'd probably rather have thoughts of, I'm glad I was able to leave X amount of dollars to my kids. I'm glad I didn't have to search for subsidized housing that no longer exists. Kids can inherit your money, but they can't inherit your FICO. Very true.
Coming at the reading of the will, and he has left you his 840 FICO score. Yeah, somehow. Oh, great. We can get into debt with Dad's FICO.
How a Credit-Led Recession Actually Unfolds
So the last point from the Jamie Dimon article is, you know, there are different reasons why you can wind up in a recession, and what Dimon is warning about is a credit-led recession, where this is not companies that are laying people off all of a sudden, but this follows the cycle for every up and down that I've seen in the economy over my lifetime, that when things are going well, you get lenders out there that start making loans that make no frickin' sense. Well, and that's part of this article too. And so what happens is that now people get overextended by creditors trying to make a profit and be greedy and stuff like that. So in a credit-led recession, banks and lenders start pulling back, so businesses now have to tighten their standards, reduce their expenses. That causes layoffs and reductions, and that's how the dominoes start falling.
Why Everyone Looks Richer Than You
Yeah, I want to kind of break it down for you guys. Just try to make it as simple as possible how this affects you, why these tea leaves, you know, what these tea leaves are saying. But think about this. You're on this call, you're listening, probably because it's a call, podcast, whatever you want to call it. You're listening probably because you have debt.
Now, here's what you're having a hard time, you know, wrapping your head around when you go out outside, restaurants, go out Friday night, whatever. When we're talking about the economy is bad, the economy is bad, right? You go out and you know you have all this debt. You know, everything's so expensive: gas, everything, groceries. Everything is just astra-fuckingomical right now.
And then you go out and the restaurants are full. Everything is full. There's people everywhere. People spending money like it's nothing. People buying new cars, buying new…
And you start going, everybody is rich but me, right? Everybody has a ton of money. But what you're seeing, guys, you're seeing credit at work. You're seeing people don't have all this cash that you're seeing out there. They have credit.
They have credit cards. They're able to get SoFi to give them $50,000 for no earthly reason why they should be able to get a $50,000 loan looking at their financials. So you've got all this extra credit going out there. That's how people are able to afford to do everything. But when that credit starts to get clawed back, which is what Jamie Dimon's talking about, when that starts to go away, when the credit card limits start to get chopped down, guess what happens?
People stop going to restaurants. They stop buying cars. They stop going out because they don't have any more credit and they don't have any cash in the bank, right? That's when the economy just starts to take that huge hit, when the people stop spending. The economy doesn't care if people are spending credit or their own cash in the moment, right?
It's an illusion, is really what it is. And as soon as that credit goes away, bam, everything's going to stop. Everybody that was just kind of phoning it in and doing the I'm Instagram rich, I'm out, but it's all on credit cards, that's all going to stop. And then businesses are going to start to go under. Car sales are going to go down.
All these, you know, retail outlets are going to start to suffer, right? And then you have this domino effect. People start getting laid off. That's what's going to happen. It's ironic that it is.
Almost un-American for you to get yourself in a situation where things are so tight that you cannot go out and spend. Because the reason we're called consumers, and the reason that we live in a capitalistic society, is because our job is to consume. I don't know how many people will remember it, but after the World Trade Centers fell, you know, after the whole thing, and our world came to a halt, George Bush, the president at the time, came out and said, Everyone needs to get back to spending, because spending is what drives the economy. If everybody just holes up in their house and stops spending, the ripple effect is terrible. Yeah, and people don't have money to spend.
They have credit to spend, for the most part. And when that credit goes away, they're not going to be out there spending, and the economy is going to—I don't know if it's going to tank. I don't know how hard the landing is going to be. I don't know if it's going to be, Oh, that plane came in pretty hard. I need to see a chiropractor, or I need a surgeon.
I don't know how hard that's going to be, but it's going to be different. Well, we have the impact of AI coming at the same time, and I think the statistic is 40% of Americans can't afford a $500 emergency. Yeah. Yeah, and people, they're listening to this and they're saying, Okay, well, it's all well and good, but there's nothing I can do in the short term about it. But what you can do is get yourself prepared.
And the way you get prepared, the fastest way to get prepared is get rid of the 50 grand in debt you have. Get rid of the 100 grand in debt you have. Fuck the FICO. Get yourself out of debt so when this stuff does start to happen and gas still stays up at seven bucks a gallon and whatever. You can't control gas prices.
You can't control grocery prices, but you can control your ability to absorb those prices. You need F-you money. I don't… Yeah. I don't remember who the comedian was that did a whole bit about that.
I'm surprised you don't remember. I, I, um, gosh darn it, I think it was, um, I don't know if they did the bit in the show, but it was, um, God, it was the guy on Roseanne. Oh, what's his name? Yeah. John Goodman.
But he— John Goodman, I think is what you're thinking of, but it was in a different movie. It wasn't on Roseanne, right? He did this kind of monologue about you need fuck-you money. I think it was him, wasn't it? I don't remember.
After the podcast, I shall find it. So the total U.S. credit card debt right now is 1.28 trillion. It's the highest of all time.
Settlement Got Harder: What Changed
All right, what's the next article you want to talk about from GetOutOfDebt.org? Well, the next one, actually I went way back a little bit a couple weeks ago, and this one was, How much can you settle a debt for? And it said the real numbers, and it actually caught my eye. And the reason it kind of goes along with this theme of fuck-your-FICO is because when you're talking about fuck your FICO, you're talking about getting rid of the debt, doing things like a bankruptcy or a settlement or anything that would cause your FICO score to take a hit in exchange for getting out of the debt, right? So this article just talks about, you know, real numbers and what you can usually expect.
But it caught my eye because I'm seeing some different things even from this article, and so I wanted to bring it up because creditors are getting maybe going along with the whole, you know, tightening theme there. I'm noticing that a lot of debts with debt buyers… These debt buyers are actually getting more aggressive than they used to be, where the old school kind of thinking was, oh yeah, you just let it charge off, and these guys bought it for pennies on the dollar and you probably settle it. Yeah, 25, 30, 35 cents on the dollar. I'm not saying those deals don't exist, but they're definitely fewer and far between post-COVID than they used to be.
And what I'm just seeing real-world stuff is oftentimes settling with the original creditor, if you can, if you can come up with the funds, you often can get the best deals with the original creditor versus letting it charge off. That's, again, this stuff ebbs and flows, guys. It changes. But right now, things seem to be trending toward much more aggressive the longer you let it go, especially in certain states. There are definitely some states that are much more litigious than others.
Zombie Second Mortgages From 2008
Yeah, look what happened with the second mortgages from the housing crisis. You know, those zombie debts are coming back because they're being bought up and now they're being aggressively collected on. And people thought that second mortgage from that house in 2008 is gone, and it's not. Yeah, I don't think we got a chance. I think that was on our board to talk about last week, but I don't know if we actually—I think we ran out of time, or maybe we didn't and I just can't remember.
But do we get a chance to talk about that clip that I think I sent you or you sent it to me, where it was this investor basically talking about that's his business, is he goes and he finds these 10-year-old, you know, second mortgages and just starts suing—not even suing, just starts foreclosure process on people just out of the blue and starts taking their house. You know, second mortgages all have liens against the properties. Yeah. Yeah, he just went right into foreclosure, like, Oh, you owe $50,000. Oh, we can't pay $50,000.
Foreclosure, no problem. Yeah. Yeah, I don't think we got into that, but yeah, bottom line is get out of debt. And if you have a second mortgage that you think is gone from the '08 crisis, be careful, because it might not be. You know, I think the lesson to be learned, and this is, again, this is why people should reach out to you, Damon Day, D-A-M-O-N D-A-Y dot com, is because this stuff is complicated.
I don't want you to panic. I don't want you to be afraid. I don't want—I want you to have answers and to seek clarity and to make the best decisions for yourself, rather than, you know, I don't want you to be the windshield or the bug. I want you to have, you know, information and make educated answers because, like, we're talking about settlement right now. I love the people who say to me, I am not going to go bankrupt because I have a moral obligation to repay my debt, so I'm going to settle it.
Uh, you know, the pain half is still not all, but it makes me feel better. Okay, I understand that, but, you know, let's not lie. Yeah. And I always want to clarify, again, I'm not saying, you know, don't think, oh, if you call Damon for advice, he's going to tell you, fuck your FICO, right? Sometimes there's very good reasons or you're in situations where we can solve your debt problem and not have to worry about hurting your FICO.
In fact, we can start improving the FICO right away. Again, I'm pro-FICO. I'm just pro-understanding how it works and understanding when it's worthless, right? Understanding how you can use it to your advantage, 100%. I'm totally all about it.
You know, doing things that you can to manipulate the FICO to your advantage, 100%, all about it. I didn't create the FICO, you know, hate the game, not the player, right? I'm all about manipulating the FICO to your advantage, legally, of course. If that gives you one up, I mean, they would do it to you. It's you against the banks, however you want to see it.
You don't matter to them at all. So why you feel this, like, huge moral obligation to them or this loyalty to them? That's between you and them. You know, it's like, well, they'll cut your credit line after 25 years of never missed payments like that if they felt it was good for their bottom line. They don't care who you are.
I like the American Express guys that, you know, have the whatever the black card or whatever it is above it, who say, I was having a bad day and I was on the phone with American Express rep and I just, I just lost it. And, you know, after 30 years of being a loyal customer, they canceled my card and that's it. Yeah. And American Express, hell hath no fury like an American Express rep that's been wronged. American Express is very vindictive.
They are the most vindictive. You do something that pisses them off and you might not ever get an American Express card again. Document it. If you're on the phone with American Express and you feel like you're losing your cool, the best thing you can do is just accidentally disconnect the call. Just call Bank of America and take it out on them.
You'll be better off. Yeah, they are incredible.
Free Tool — Statute of Limitations Checker: Dealing with old debt? The free Statute of Limitations Checker tells you if the collection clock has expired in your state — including the zombie debt and clock-restarting traps collectors use. Check My Status →
Debt Buyers Are Going Straight to Court
So people buy debt statements. This article, how much can you usually settle a debt for, talks about how some debt buyers are buying debts for two to four cents on the dollar, and they think they've been to Reddit or some other place, and they think that these people who now own your debt will be happy to take just anything. But you said that is not actually what's happening. No, it's changing a lot. And a lot of these collectors that used to just, you know, hope to get whatever they could and try to make a profit, now they're just going to litigation, right?
And so it's like, yeah, you can try to drag it out, but you're rolling the dice. And yeah, if you get three or four years behind, then maybe you might be able to get a better deal. But oftentimes you're just going to get hit with the lawsuit. And then once you get hit with the lawsuit, You can still negotiate with the attorney, but then it's going to be an even higher amount, you know? So the old school ways of just, oh, just let it charge off and I'll drag it out, and, you know, that guy paid five cents on the dollar, so I'm going to offer him, you know, 15 cents and he'll be happy to take it.
Those are gone. Cost a couple hundred bucks to file a lawsuit and get a default judgment because you're probably not going to respond to it. Ninety percent of people who get sued do not respond and automatically get a default judgment. Yeah, so where a lot of people mess up is they just keep dragging it out, not taking a good deal because it was 40 cents on the dollar or 50 cents on the dollar, and they read something on Reddit, oh, I wait longer and I'll get 20 cents on the dollar. And then what they end up getting is a lawsuit, and now the attorney's talking 80 cents on the dollar.
So it's not just a matter of you don't pay and eventually you get 20 cents on the dollar. You got to be—if you're going to settle your debt, you got to go into that with a plan and an understanding of your specific creditors and your situation. And that's why, again, when you're looking at something like settlement, you should also look at every other option available because just because it sounds kind of neat doesn't mean it's the right strategy. You know what's cheaper than settlement? Bankruptcy.
Free Tool — I'm Being Sued for Debt Guide: Being sued by a creditor or debt collector? The free I'm Being Sued Guide gives you a personalized action plan — deadlines, defenses, and options based on your state. Most states require a response within 20–30 days. Get My Action Plan →
Terms Matter as Much as the Discount
Well, so—yeah, and you got to do the math right too, because you don't want to be the person that says they wanted 70 cents on the dollar and I said, no way, but then you look at the terms they were going to give you, like 10 years, no interest. That's a good deal. Yeah, so, yeah, terms matter a lot. It's not always about just what is the actual percentage off, because when you look at what you were paying, you were paying 25% a year, and if you can get a deal even at no interest over five years, even if it's not a settlement, but especially if it's a settlement, even if it's only 25% off but it's no interest over four years, yeah, you're thinking, oh, I owe 10,000, I paid back 7,500, I only saved $2,500. No, you didn't, because if you owed $10,000 at 25%, it was going to take you five years to pay off that 10 grand.
At 25%, you saved a lot more than $2,500. You probably saved $7,500, but don't quote me on it because I didn't do the math, okay? I just made it up. Somewhere around there. All right.
I didn't do the math. Hey, don't follow me. I don't read. Is that—who's that? That's Bill, not Billingville, Bill Burr.
That one always cracked me up. Don't follow me. I don't read. He is funny. All right, what's the next one?
The Venmo Cash Advance Trap
Oh, the next one is a post that came out today. This is actually something that happened to me. If you have Venmo and you have a transaction, mine was I was getting the driveway power washed and the house power washed, and they said, Well, we only take Venmo, so I don't like to connect my bank, you know, to outside things. So one of the options was you can use your credit card to fund the Venmo payment. Wait, did they tell you before or after?
They told me after. Then I would have said, That sounds like a you problem, because I don't have Venmo. Here's what I have. Do you want it or not? Typical non-confrontational Steve.
I'd have been like, I don't have Venmo. What else you want? So anyway, proceed, sir. The problem is that with Venmo, if you use a credit card to fund Venmo, they actually—actually Venmo doesn't do this. It's your bank.
The banks actually consider that to be a person-to-person transfer, and they classify it as a cash advance. So you're going to get hit with—they might, whoever you're working with might add some money because you're using a credit card. Then you're going to get hit with a 4 or 5 percent cash advance fee on the transaction, and then you're going to get hit with 29 or 30 percent cash advance interest rate. But here's the thing that kills me the most is if you go and look at your cardholder agreements, you will find out that you absolutely cannot repay the high cash advance that you're being charged until you pay the entire regular balance and pay off the cash advance. So you take a cash advance, you are stuck if you can't pay off those cards at the higher rate.
So the banks that do this are Chase, Bank of America, Capital One, Citibank, Wells Fargo, U.S. Bank, and Barclays. The two that don't are American Express and Discover. Jamie Dimon, say it ain't so, bro. I think what's really funny is that Venmo has their own credit card, and guess what?
It's a cash advance. Well, so a workaround, if you're in a situation where you really like to use Venmo and you enjoy that or whatever, that's something that you do, and you're also like Steve that doesn't like to link a debit card, obviously, or, you know, direct ACH to Venmo right out of there, you could either use Discover or Amex, as Steve mentioned, or if you don't have one of those, kind of a pain in the butt workaround, but again, if these things are true and you definitely like to use Venmo and you don't have an Amex or a Discover, then you could technically open up a different checking account that is not your main checking account. Again, I know it's a pain in the butt, but I didn't make the rules. And you could link that checking account. So if you're worried about people getting access to your checking, at least they would be getting access potentially to a checking account that is not your main one.
Right, and then you can just put cash in there for when you're going to do Venmo transactions, link that to your debit card, and there you go. Right, that's good advice. And if you pay your card off in full every month, then you don't have to worry about taking forever to be able to get to the cash advance to be able to pay it off. Yeah, I mean, we pay off our cards in full every month, but that's how— But you can't, no avoiding the 5% fee. No, that's how this surfaced, because on the statement it was like, And plus the cash advance fee.
Like, cash advance? What? Ruh-roh. Yep. All right.
So, Damon?
Closing: Your FICO Bounces Back
I need to go pick up my dog. I don't have any more articles, so I think we'd be done. I need to go pick up my dog. Okay, well, the takeaway is, Steve, what's the takeaway? What?
Oh, fuck the FICO. Fuck the FICO. Come on, bro. Have you been here today? You're on this podcast with me, right?
Am I? That was the whole theme. Don't fear the FICO. Fuck the FICO. It's catchy.
It's going to catch on. I hope more people can rally behind that. FICO is fine, but not when it's not. In my lifetime, I've had great credit and I've had bad credit. I'd rather have great credit, but I don't need to make anybody feel better.
Your FICO is actually resilient. It will bounce back faster than you can imagine. Bankruptcy, settlement, I don't care. Your FICO will bounce back long before you would have ever paid off your debt following Dave Ramsey. Guarantee.
Yeah, said the guy who went bankrupt and got a Capital One credit card in the mail the same day. Same effing day, people. Same day. Here's your discharge. Here's your Capital One credit card.
Tell me how bankruptcy screws your life up for 10 years. Tell me. I was also rolling a Platinum Escalade with five TVs in it when my bankruptcy was like three years old. Not that that's what I want you to go out and do. I'm just saying I could do it, and I financed it with the bankruptcy.
Yeah. I remember when I bought a motorcycle, and it was like within 10 years of my bankruptcy. And I remember being at the dealership, and I saw that line on the application. It was like, Have you filed bankruptcy in the last 10 years? And I said to the credit person, Is this going to disqualify me?
She goes, No. She goes, It doesn't matter to me. It's just a box on the form, you know. It's not going to stop anything. And again, I always put it out there, we're not saying bankruptcy is always the right answer either.
We're just saying we're going to look at everything. It doesn't hurt. Look at everything. Don't automatically think anything that hurts my FICO is not a good answer. Oftentimes it actually is because, and hear me again when I say this again, your FICO will bounce back faster than you could have paid off your debt in a traditional way in almost every scenario.
All right, Damon, on that note, I will see ya. Yeah, Jamie Dimon wants to lend you money, so he doesn't care if you file bankruptcy. He wants to give you more. Peace.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a good credit score mean I am managing my money well?
No. Credit scoring was built to help lenders sort applicants by how likely they are to produce a profitable, repaid loan. It cannot see your savings, your income, your emergency fund, or whether you can sleep at night. You can have an 830 and be one repair bill from disaster, or a 560 and a paid-off house.
Can my credit card company cut my limit even if I have never been late?
Yes. The credit line is not your property — you have the use of it at the lender's discretion. When lenders get nervous about the economy they reduce risk by cutting limits and closing accounts, and a perfect payment history does not exempt you. If you owe $20,000 against $40,000 in limits and those limits drop to $25,000, your utilization jumps from 50% to 80% and your score falls, with no action on your part.
Is available credit the same as an emergency fund?
No, and treating it that way is one of the most damaging mistakes I see. People throw every spare dollar at their balances and keep no cash, reasoning that their unused credit covers emergencies. Then the limits get cut and they have neither credit nor cash. Keep roughly three months of expenses in actual money even while paying down debt.
How long does it really take for a credit score to recover after bankruptcy or settlement?
Much less time than most people expect, and typically less time than it would have taken to pay the debt off the traditional way — during which the balances are suppressing the score anyway. The honest picture is neither "your life is over for ten years" nor "everything is instantly fine." There are hurdles, and they tend to be solvable: being declined by one institution and approved by another with the same report and the same income is routine, because lenders set their own policies.
Is it better to settle with the original creditor or wait for a debt buyer?
The old advice was to let the account charge off and settle cheaply with whoever bought it. That has changed. Debt buyers are moving to litigation faster because filing suit is inexpensive and most people sued never file an answer, so the case ends in a default judgment. If you can find the funds, settling with the original creditor before charge-off is now frequently the better deal — and how litigious your state is matters a great deal.
How should I compare two debt settlement offers?
Compare the total you will actually pay and over what period, not the discount percentage. If you owe $10,000 at 25% interest, an offer of $7,500 payable over four years at no interest looks like only a 25% discount, but the interest you stop paying is real money that never appears in that percentage. A smaller discount with good terms routinely beats a bigger discount with bad ones.
Can a second mortgage from the 2008 housing crisis still be collected?
It may be. Many people assumed those loans simply vanished because nobody called for years, but a great number were bought by investors. Because a second mortgage carries a lien against the property, the holder does not have to sue you the way an unsecured creditor would — it can move toward foreclosure directly. If this describes you, find out where that loan stands on your own timeline rather than from a notice.
Why did I get a cash advance fee for using my credit card on a payment app?
Because your card issuer, not the app, decides how the transaction is classified — and peer-to-peer transfers funded by a credit card are frequently coded as cash advances rather than purchases. That means an immediate fee, a higher interest rate than your purchase rate, and no grace period, so interest starts the day of the transaction. Issuers differ, and the answer for your specific card is in your cardholder agreement under "cash advance."
How do I pay off a high-rate cash advance balance faster?
Pay meaningfully above your minimum. Federal law (Regulation Z, 12 CFR § 1026.53) requires an issuer to allocate anything you pay above the required minimum to your highest-rate balance first, which is usually the cash advance. The same regulation's commentary says it does not restrict how the issuer allocates the minimum payment itself, so paying only the minimum can leave a cash advance sitting there accruing interest indefinitely.