On November 8, 2011 Legal Helpers Debt Resolution aka Macey, Aleman, Hyslip & Searns filed suit against Lisa magian, Attorney General of Illinois and Bret Adams, Secretary of the Illinois Department of Financial & Professional Regulation.
The case was filed by James Abbott of Litchfield Cavo LLP and Richard Epstein and Rebecca Bratter of Greenspoon Marder, PA.
The suit claims the Defendants denied equal protection and the deprivation of property and liberty interests without due process of law in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.
LHDR states that the case details the wrongdoings of State officials, who deliberately acted beyond their authority and are intentionally violating the U.S. Constitution, the Illinois Constitution and Illinois law.
The statement is made that the Illinois Debt Settlement Statute does not apply to attorneys and that the Defendants unlawfully applied that law in order to do something not one of them has the power to do; regulate the practice of law.
The suit goes after the Defendants in their roles as state officials and personally, stating, “The highest executive officials in the state are not protected by absolute immunity from damages liability arising from their official acts.”
It appears this engagement with Legal Helpers Debt Resolution and the State of Illinois will become a landmark case in the determination of if debt settlement services may be provided by lawyers and loophole debt relief statutes. The previously filed case by the State of Illinois against Legal Helpers Debt Resolution is ongoing.
As stated in the suit filed by LHDR, they claim that neither the Debt Settlement Act nor the Consumer Fraud Act apply to attorneys.
LHDR is also disturbed that Madigan issued a press release “that castigated Macey, Aleman, Hyslip, & Searns by name and referred to it’s services as a “scam.”
This is the press release they are referring to.
March 2, 2011
ATTORNEY GENERAL MADIGAN: POCKETBOOK ISSUES CONTINUE TO TOP CONSUMER CONCERNS IN 2010
Madigan Files Lawsuit Aimed at New Wave of Consumer Debt Settlement Scams
Chicago – Attorney General Lisa Madigan today released her list of top 10 consumer complaints, detailing concerns of the 170,000 consumers who contacted her office’s Consumer Protection Division in 2010. In anticipation of National Consumer Protection Week, Madigan said that the top complaints involved consumer debt as the job loss and home foreclosures continue to take a toll on Illinois consumers.
That consumer debt again topped the list of concerns in 2010 mirrors what Madigan’s office has seen in recent years as consumers struggle with pocketbook issues in a down economy. Complaints related to residential mortgages ranked highest among consumer debt concerns, showing that, much like 2009, people are still fighting to stay in their homes. Many consumers also contacted Madigan’s office over credit card debt and abusive collection practices.
“The economic crisis continues to affect consumers in Illinois,” Attorney General Madigan said. “People are struggling just to make ends meet. Consumers should know my office is here to help protect them against financial abuse and from con artists who are taking advantage of these tough times to make a quick buck.”
Included in the more than 7,000 consumer debt complaints filed with Madigan’s office is a new attempt to evade recent reforms aimed at protecting consumers. Last year, Madigan successfully led an effort to pass the Debt Settlement Consumer Protection Act, which bans upfront fees debt settlement companies charge and requires they can only collect fees if a consumer’s debt is actually settled.
Attorney General Madigan today filed a lawsuit against a national legal firm that has unlawfully charged upfront fees to consumers in Bureau, Champaign, Kendall, Will and Cook counties. Madigan’s suit, filed in Sangamon County Circuit Court, alleges Legal Helpers Debt Resolution LLC unlawfully charged consumers upfront fees for debt settlement services with promises to make them debt free. But, in fact, they never lowered the consumers’ debt and actually left them worse off financially.
The lawsuit alleges Legal Helpers Debt Resolution, based in Chicago, illegally charged fees upfront under a guise that attorneys, who are exempted from an upfront fee ban, were providing the debt settlement service to consumers, enabling them to charge the initial fees. In fact, Madigan alleges, attorneys with Legal Helpers Debt Resolution only served as a front to the business, and debt settlement service was contracted out to non-lawyer, third-party companies.
Attorney General Madigan also today detailed the 27,630 formal complaints lodged with her office in 2010 by consumers affected by scams and fraud:
Consumer Debt Complaints Rank First in 2010
Complaints from consumers involving residential mortgages ranked highest among debt concerns, but also included problems with credit card debt and the availability of short-term, high-interest loans. The top consumer debt issues reported in 2010 include:
More than 3,800 homeowners filed residential mortgage complaints with Madigan’s office in 2010. This mirrors what the Attorney General’s Office saw in 2009 as the foreclosure crisis began to expand beyond those homeowners who were placed in risky loans they could in reality never afford. Last year’s complaints reflects a continued deepening of the foreclosure crisis as Illinois homeowners struggle under long-term unemployment and find they can no longer make their mortgage payments.
In 2010, Madigan’s Consumer Fraud Bureau helped secure an estimated $25 million in mortgage-related savings, including loan modifications for borrowers. In the wake of the foreclosure crisis, Madigan established the Homeowner Helpline (1-866-544-7151) to provide direct assistance for borrowers at risk of foreclosure. Since the hotline launched in October 2008, more than 32,000 have called the Attorney General’s office for help. Madigan encourages consumers struggling to stay current with mortgage payments to contact the helpline to learn more about their rights and the options available to them to try to save their homes.
In 2010, more than 1,200 consumers reported complaints about collection agencies, including complaints that collection efforts were made without verifying a consumer actually owed the debt, through abusive tactics or by misleading demand documents made to look like official court documents.
Credit Card Companies
More than 700 consumers sought help for credit card company issues. Consumers reported problems with credit card balance transfers and introductory rate offers, or being charged a higher interest rate than originally quoted. Madigan said it is important for consumers to know they can dispute charges to their credit cards directly with the credit card company or call her Consumer Fraud Bureau for assistance.
Identity Theft Complaints Rank Second
Concerns surrounding identity theft remained high for consumers in 2010, with 3,861 complaints reported. A significant number of those complaints involved:
Credit card complaints (1,082), including reports of fraudulent charges to existing accounts and thieves opening new credit card accounts in the names of ID theft victims;
Utility company complaints (527), concerning fraudulent utility accounts, such as cell phones or gas and electric service, opened in a victim’s name; and
Bank fraud complaints (355), including complaints of stolen checks and new bank accounts opened in a victim’s name and fraudulent withdrawals from a victim’s bank account.
Most of the consumers who filed these complaints to Madigan’s office in 2010 did so by contacting her Identity Theft Hotline (1-866-999-5630). The hotline has received more than 29,000 calls since it launched in February 2006. Trained advocates and attorneys answer calls to the hotline, working with consumers to help them by reporting the crime to local law enforcement and financial institutions, repairing their credit and protecting their identity. – Source
The full suit by LHDR is 45 pages and you are more than welcome to read the entire complaint here.
I can always use your help. If you have a tip or information you want to share, you can get it to me confidentially if you click here.