I graduated from a college in the United States that closed.
My federal student loans are current thanks to the pay as you earn program, but my private loans are in default.
I don’t currently live in the United States and have been granted Citizenship in the country I currently reside in, and at present, I have no intentions of returning to the United States.
My private student loans have been in default for over a year, yet I have always kept paying them whatever I could afford,
I have not paid them anything. I keep seeing my loan amount rise and rise, and I keep getting further and further behind.
My question to you is, being that I do not live in the US, am I better off stop paying this loan that is in default?
I always figured it would look good for me if I ever got taken to court to show the judge that I was at least paying them something, but since I never plan to return to the United States, does this even matter?
Should I keep doing what I am doing, or should I stop paying the defaulted private loan?
What a great question.
I understand the thinking behind the partial payment approach. The reality, though, is that it doesn’t matter. If you were taken to court, the primary issue would be if you were behind in payments. A partial payment puts you in default but a little bit slower. You are still not making the minimum payment, so it is a noble but technically worthless effort.
However, I think people that struggle with emotional issues with debts should feel free to make partial payments if they want. However, those partial payments will only keep the account alive if they wanted it to grow old and no longer be covered under the Statute of Limitations.
So, a partial payment is a smart move if you have an emotional justification for doing that. But outside of that, the payment is either affordable, or it’s not. If it is not affordable, you can attempt to work with the creditor to get a lower payment. If they won’t budge, then it is what it is.
This Will Sound Crazy
While we live in the most modern world ever, the field of international collections is very archaic and ineffective.
The reality is that there is little chance you will be pursued over the private student loan debt. The reasons are mostly technical. They may try to send you emails or find you but the odds that the account will be perfected and placed for collections in the country you live in are very slim.
Now the Statute of Limitations (SOL) would give you an argument to make if a creditor attempted to sue you after a period of time expires. The SOL would not prevent you from being sued.
If you have bank accounts in the U.S. and have a judgment against you, a creditor could always attempt to levy them.
The SOL may also be paused when you are outside of the United States.
There are actually some valid reasons to not pay the debt anymore.
Can I Tell You What to Do?
Vance, I can’t command you what to do. All I can do is give you the facts as I know them. You will have to make your own decision.
If you do decide to stop paying, expect the student loan company to try and find you, send emails, or contact people back in the U.S. to try and locate you. If you accept this and be patient, the efforts will cease.
If you have a U.S. based telephone number a collector has on file, they may continue to call it. If they have your email, they could email.
The reality as it stands today is that a foreign account is a pain in the butt for the collector. You will become a low priority, and the collector will most likely move on to lower hanging fruit.
If you default, the creditor could sue you where you used to live and get a judgment against you since you would probably not raise a defense.
However, even if they did that, it does not prevent you from traveling in and out of the United States. The U.S. Customs and Border Protection does not enforce civil conflicts, so in and out, you will be able to go.
So given the facts you’ve presented:
- You do not live in the United States.
- You are not planning to move back to the United States.
- You are behind on your private student loans.
- You can’t afford the minimum payment.
- You can’t afford to bring the account current.
It would not be illogical to stop paying.
If you latter wanted to deal with the private student loan debt, you could always attempt to settle the debt later. You will have the leverage at that point. A debt coach that can give you some excellent guidance on this issue is Damon Day.
But Be Prepared
When the account is sufficiently past due, the private student loan holder will charge-off the debt as a bad debt and issue you an IRS 1099-C form. If you are not insolvent, you may owe income tax on the charged-off debt. If you are insolvent, you can use this form to avoid the tax.
You are not alone. I'm here to help. There is no need to suffer in silence. We can get through this. Tomorrow can be better than today. Don't give up.
Do you have a question you'd like to ask me for free? Go ahead and click here.
- Who Knew TitleMax Sucked This Bad? - February 23, 2023
- Litigation Practice Group Lawsuit by Business Partner All Service Financial – We Want Our Money - January 24, 2023
- HomeAdvisor and Angi to Pay Up To $7.2 Million and Stop Deceptively Marketing its Leads for Home Improvement Projects - January 23, 2023
4 thoughts on “I’m Not Coming Back to the U.S. So Can I Stop Paying My Private Student Loans?”
Thank you for your reply Steve, so it sounds like you are saying that there is little they can do to me. For what it is worth, I had two private loans with two companies. One of the companies worked with me and I managed to pay this private loan off. The current Private Loan in question is owned by Navient. Navient also manages some of my federal loans as well. They always add money to what the department of education says my payments should be…at first I would contact them and they would fix it…then they stopped. I had to report them to the President of the US at the time who passed my complaint on to another Company. Navient of course acted innocent and stated it was a mistake. They keep making this same mistake though. This is why I am considering stopping my payments to them. They have already been sending me emails asking me to call them. I always respond and tell them that I do not live in the United States and all I have is a prepaid cell phone. Even though their number is toll free, it is not toll free for me. I requested to communicate via email…they never respond. I know you can’t tell me what to do, but I was wondering if just stop paying would be better for me than just paying these small payments and it sounds like you are saying that it would.
Just make sure you stay current on your federal loans, even if it is some Income-Driven program. Private student loans are for now but federal loans are forever.
Asked question about not coming back to the U.S. and defaulting on private student loans.