How to Handle a Consumer Complaint Like a Pro

Your company’s reputation isn’t built when things are going great. It’s built when something goes wrong, and everyone is watching how you handle it.

Yet, I keep watching businesses take a small complaint—something that could have been solved with a simple, “Hey, let’s make this right”—and turn it into a full-blown PR disaster because they can’t stop themselves from being defensive, blaming the customer, or hiding behind fine print like it’s some kind of legal force field.

Listen, a customer complaint isn’t a disaster—it’s a golden opportunity to show future customers how you treat people when things go sideways. If you do it right, that complaint can turn into a five-star review and a loyal customer. But if you do it wrong? Well, congrats, you just tanked your own reputation.

There Are Two Ways Companies End Up on This Site

1️⃣ A consumer feels ignored and has no other option but to complain publicly.

2️⃣ You got sued in federal court.

That’s it. That’s the whole list. And both of these could have been avoided if you just handled complaints the right way.

Lawsuits are public record, and I cover them here because people deserve to know when a debt relief company is in legal trouble.

And let me tell you—most of these lawsuits could have been avoided if the company had just fixed the issue before it turned into a legal circus.

But instead, they did one of the worst things possible…

Hiding Behind Fine Print = Regulatory Target on Your Back

If your first response to a complaint is:

💬 “Well, technically, our contract says we don’t have to give you a refund.”

or

💬 “Actually, our agreement says you can’t post negative reviews about us.”

Then congratulations, you just threw gasoline on the fire.

Because you know who doesn’t care about your fine print?

🔴 Regulators.
🔴 Judges.
🔴 The internet.

The worst thing you can do is try to silence unhappy customers with a legal clause.

👉 Regulators love cases like that. They’ll come in, investigate your business, and once they start digging? They’ll find everything—every bad review, every unhappy customer, and every shady refund policy you’ve ever tried to enforce.

And let me tell you—that’s a dumb business strategy.

The Best Companies Solve Problems Before They Become Lawsuits

Let me tell you a story about how this works in the real world.

I once hired a contractor to build a deck. Halfway through, I realized they’d completely screwed something up. I was furious.

I called the contractor and told him, “We’re gonna deal with this. Tomorrow morning. First thing.”

The next morning, he showed up five minutes early, walked up to me, and said:

💬 “Steve, I take full responsibility. I won’t stop until we fix this, and you’re happy with our work.”

And just like that—my anger disappeared.

There was no fight, no legal threats, no negative reviews. He just owned the problem and fixed it.

And because of that, I ended up referring three more customers to him.

That’s how you handle complaints.

Want to See a Company That Gets It? Look at Apple.

Apple products are expensive—but people keep buying them because they trust the brand. And a big part of that trust comes from their customer service.

I once walked into an Apple Store in San Francisco after flying in from Europe. My power adapter didn’t work in the U.S., so I told them I needed to buy a new one.

Instead of making me jump through hoops, the employee ran to the back, grabbed a new adapter, and said:

💬 “This one’s on us. Thanks for being an Apple customer.”

No drama. No excuses. Just great service.

Now, compare that to how most debt relief companies handle complaints:

🚩 Ignore emails.
🚩 Refuse refunds.
🚩 Blame the customer.
🚩 Get defensive online.

And then when a lawsuit comes knocking, they’re shocked.

Do This to Handle a Complaint Like a Pro

If you actually want to fix problems instead of making them worse, follow these steps:

1. Fix Problems Before They Go Public

Follow up with customers. If someone has an issue, solve it before it turns into a public complaint or a lawsuit.

2. Own the Issue

Even if you think the complaint is unfair, say:

💬 “I hear you. Let’s figure out how to fix this.”

That sentence alone will diffuse 90% of complaints.

3. Don’t Let a Complaint Turn Into a Lawsuit

If someone is angry enough to sue, you had plenty of chances to prevent it.

4. Never Hide Behind Fine Print

If your best defense is “but our contract says…”, you’ve already lost. Regulators don’t care about your refund policy—they care about whether customers are getting what they paid for.

5. Assign One Point of Contact

Nothing is worse than being bounced around. Give the customer one person to talk to.

6. Stick to Your Promises

If you say, “I’ll call you tomorrow at 2 PM,” then do it.

7. Focus on What You CAN Do

Customers don’t care what you can’t do. Tell them what you will do.

8. Refunds Are Cheaper Than Lawsuits

I’ve covered so many lawsuits that started over a simple refund request. If you’d just refunded the money upfront, you’d be saving yourself thousands in legal fees.

9. Build a Reputation That Drowns Out Complaints

Encourage happy customers to leave positive reviews. If you have hundreds of good reviews, a few complaints won’t destroy your reputation.

Final Thought: What Kind of Company Do You Want to Be?

If you run a debt relief company, you have two choices:

1️⃣ Build a reputation for honesty and great service.
2️⃣ Ignore complaints, hide behind fine print, and eventually end up in legal trouble.

Good companies fix problems early and build trust.

Bad companies turn small issues into major lawsuits and wonder why no one trusts them.

Which one do you want to be?

The choice is yours.

Steve Rhode Debt Coach and Author

Steve Rhode is the Get Out of Debt Guy and has been helping good people with bad debt problems since 1994. You can learn more about Steve, here.

See Full Bio

Consumer Debt Consumer Bankruptcy How to Get out of Debt Money Troubles Money Personalities Budgeting Behavioral Economics Motivation Inspiration Money Management The History of Credit and Debt Getting Out of Debt Get Out of Debt Debt Settlement Credit Counseling Loan & Debt Relief Scams Debt Relief Industry Practices Exposing Deceptive Financial Services Helping Consumers Navigate Financial Hardship Consumer Advocacy Consumer Debt Expert Consumer Protection Debt Relief Scam Student Loan Bankruptcy Debt Validation Debt and Mental Health Student Loans Debt Consolidation Debt in the Military