A Law Firm Says They Can Protect Me When I Settle My Debt. – Sherrie

“Dear Steve,

I received settlement offers from my creditors. How do I ensure that they do not sell my account to another party for collections after receiving the settlement?

I was told by a debt counselor working with a local law firm that I could settle my accounts on my own, but creditors have been known to then sell the account and another firm then goes after you to get the remainder.

I was told by this debt counselor that with their service that when they take over and pay the settlements it would be illegal. This is a reputable law firm that is rated an A+ with BBB. Two of my accounts were turned over to collections for settlements.

I am able to pay all of my settlement offers with a home equity loan from my bank and once I do, I want to make sure that I am free and clear.

Can creditors agree to a settlement, then once they receive it sell the account to someone else to continue to collect? If so, how can I ensure that this will not happen?

If the account was turned over to a third party such as a law office or collection agency, can the creditor still do this after settlement has been agreed upon?


Woman Whispers a Secret

Dear Sherrie,

Well what the debt counselor told you is a load of misinformation. (I so wanted to use a different word.)

It is really a very simple issue. The key is documentation and retention.

People run into trouble because they either lost the documentation on the settled debt or they never got the offer and proof of acceptance in writing.

When you settle a debt you will want to make sure the creditor has put the offer in writing and states the settlement payment is for the full satisfaction of the outstanding debt. I would suggest you make sure this letter clearly identifies the account in question by original creditor, account number and balance.

See also  Representative for Debt Settlement Law Firm Tells Me New FTC Rules Don't Apply to Them

Do not make a settlement payment until you get this offer in your hand. And when you do make your payment, make sure you have some documentation to show the funds were received and cash by the creditor.

Next, attach the proof of payment to the settlement letter and keep that documentation in whatever safe place you keep your other important papers. Never throw it away.

I have seen instances of creditors coming back years later and saying there never was such an agreement but all of those instances were dealt with swiftly when the documentation and proof was provided.

It’s only those that never kept the proof that had problems later, in my experience.

If an account is with collections, you will want to make sure the settlement letter they provide is from the original creditor or provides some statement the original creditor has agreed to the settlement. I have seen some cases where a collection company said they would settle and then an original creditor later said they did not have the authority to make that offer. However, with the documentation in hand this is much less of an issue.

These days it can be tough to figure out if the collection company is acting as an agent of the original creditor or bought the bad debt and is now the owner.

Depending on the timing of things it is possible that an account could be turned over to an outside party if it was in the works at the time the settlement and payment came together. Much of this is just an administrative snafu that can be easily cleared up.

In my experience, if you have the offer and proof of payment then you will have little to worry about except for some administrative issue that can be easily solved.

The part that gets sticky is when you get a collections company that says they will accept a payment of $X but does not state it is for the full satisfaction of the debt. In that case I’ve seen some go back to collect the balance.

See also  Representative for Debt Settlement Law Firm Tells Me New FTC Rules Don't Apply to Them

Don’t forget, whatever the creditor or collector tells you over the phone is worthless. Make sure you get any settlement in writing and if it all looks good, make the payment promptly.

Finally, get familiar with the pros and cons of debt settlement before you jump in with both feet.

Please post your responses and follow-up messages to me on this in the comments section below.


You are not alone. I'm here to help. There is no need to suffer in silence. We can get through this. Tomorrow can be better than today. Don't give up.

Do you have a question you'd like to ask me for free? Go ahead and click here.
Damon Day - Pro Debt Coach

Follow Me
Steve Rhode is the Get Out of Debt Guy and has been helping good people with bad debt problems since 1994. You can learn more about Steve, here.
Steve Rhode
Follow Me

6 thoughts on “A Law Firm Says They Can Protect Me When I Settle My Debt. – Sherrie”

  1. What does happen (and I beleive it is more often an issue of poor data input rather that intentional selling of settled debt) is that settled debt does get subsequent collection efforts. This is an obvious violation. The frequency it occurs is the reason that consumers must have proper documentation (both of payment and fact account is settled IN FULL). Question is, when this happens what does one do? Sure, one can contact the creditor and show proof. This works sometimes. A debt settlement company can do little more than this. I have done this and still see a collector/creditor come along some time later and try to collect yet again. Some zombies are hard to kill! What’s the best thing to do? Hire a lawyer who knows what they are doing to kill the zombie (along with a small reward to the consumer). Amazingly, I have sued on these types of cases, got a recovery and a court order, only to see the zombie again! Those are the cases I really love. They are the cases that keep on giving.

    • Yes and no. This is a point many are confused about. You will have to only pay tax on the forgiven debt if you are not insolvent. If your liabilities exceed your assets you will NOT have to pay tax on the forgiven debt if you fill out IRS Form 982.

      Forgiven debt above the point where you become solvent is taxable at your ordinary income rate.


Leave a Comment