Debt Articles

CFPB Says National Collegiate Master Student Loan Trust Still Harming Consumers

Written by Steve Rhode

National Collegiate Student Loan Trust (NCSLT) is a messed up private student loan player. I still think their daily suits against people could be defeated with smart legal brains representing consumers because the debts would struggle to be validated if challenged.

The debacle over the chopped up and the divided pool of student loan debt has been raging for years now. Just look at all the past posts on this subject.

In 2017 the NCSLT entered into a settlement agreement with the CFPB to clean up the mess. One of the underlying investors objected. So every day since then it seems consumers are being sued over debts NCSLT already agreed to stop collection lawsuits and collecting past judgments. – Source

The agreed settlement offered even more for consumers that had been financially injured by the NCSLT actions.

Do You Have a Question You'd Like Steve to Answer? Click Here.

On July 20, 2020, the CFPB exasperatedly asked the Court to put this entire issue to bed. The CFPB said, “Almost three years after this case was filed, student borrowers harmed by Defendants’ illegal practices are still awaiting the remediation they deserve, and additional students who may have been similarly harmed have not been identified. No further delay is warranted.”

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

But just so this issue won’t be put to rest, the Structured Finance Association has poked their nose into this mess with a recent court filing. Basically, the Association wants this entire issue to go away on a technicality and that still leaves the underlying putrid loans consumers are shouldering the burden of.

And I get it, the Association is trying to stand up for institutional investors that are trying to make money. Hey, that’s capitalism at its finest.

But at what cost and misrepresentation is it okay to profit off consumers by bad acts?

READ  CFPB Sues National Collegiate Student Loan Trust and Enters Into Proposed Judgment

The Association states, “The Proposed Consent Judgment further poses a risk to securitization investors. These investors expect to take the risk of delinquencies and defaults in the performance of trust assets. Substantial steps are taken in the syndication and marketing process to assure investors of the quality of the assets, including extensive disclosure requirements, third party diligence reviews and, more recently, risk retention. The risk of delinquency and default is analyzed in great detail. Imposing on investors the additional and unquantifiable risk of substantial liability of the trusts, for actions which neither investors nor the trustee could promote or advocate, and which they could not in any way conduct, control or predict, would be highly destructive to the securitization market. Allowing the Bureau to overextend its enforcement authority, as it is attempting to do in this case, by choosing its own definition of “covered person” would frustrate legislative intent and legitimate contractual rights.”

One could argue this entire situation was created when the investors rushed to participate in an investment that was fatally flawed from the start. If they analyzed the investment in such great detail then why didn’t they structure the deal to avoid deceptive servicing and make sure the documentation on the loans was preserved?

And tomorrow will be another day a consumer will have their financial life trashed just because there are no adults in the room to accept responsibility and move this mess forward to a resolution.

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab



About the author

Steve Rhode

Steve Rhode is the Get Out of Debt Guy and has been helping good people with bad debt problems since 1994. You can learn more about Steve, here.

Share a Comment / Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top