Author Helanie Olen has recently released a new book title Pound Foolish: Exposing the Dark Side of the Personal Finance Industry.
In this book she discusses the blind faith of many to follow the personal finance advice of popular financial gurus without question.
She also talks about the issues surrounding financial literacy and the fallacies about it’s effectiveness.
For me it’s a real breath of fresh air to hear someone question these issues as I have for decades.
I always find it interesting that my message is to question and do research but people latch on to the advice of gurus like Orman and Ramsey, blindly. Even when it makes no sense at all.
As an example, see Dave Ramsey’s Hatred of Bankruptcy and Credit Cards Makes No Logical Sense.
The Olen interview below is worth the investment in time to watch. It will help to open your eyes to the blind trust in bad advice.
Authoritative nastiness is a very interesting term Olen uses for the advice given by financial gurus like Suze Orman, David Bach and Dave Ramsey. The pundits become very set in their ways and blame the individual for the cause of their debt problems. This puts an ufair burden on the individual for matters that are truly beyond their control, leaving them feeling guilty.
I believe that the pundits like Suze Orman, David Bach and Dave Ramsey do offer some good advice, but their fans seem more like true believers rather than independent thinking educated students.
Olen goes on to talk about the lack of proof that financial literacy makes a significant difference and that in fact some financial brands use financial literacy courses as a way to “indoctrinate” young minds to their bank or product.
This is a topic I talked about in Financial Literacy is Not a Vaccine, nor is it a Solution. It is an Excuse.
On why she loathes personal finance Gurus:
“These people are telling us, hey, just buy a few umbrellas and sand bags and no matter what wave comes your way, you’re going to be fine. And, by the way, they’re the ones selling us the sandbags and umbrellas and they don’t often disclose that.”
On why tips aren’t enough to save consumer finances:
“What they’re doing is they’re denying the pressures that are on us. Our salaries have stagnated and fallen for well over a decade now. And what they’re doing is saying, you’re going to be fine if you’re living within your means while they ignore the fact that our heath care costs have gone up at rates beyond inflation, housing has gone up at rates beyond inflation, education has gone up at rates beyond inflation.”
On why finance gurus have so much pull with consumers:
“We’re nuts when it comes to money and all we want is someone to tell us what to do. Most of us don’t want to engage with our money even though we need it, and so the idea is, hey, I’ll just follow this person and they’ll tell me what to do. We also, in this country, have a huge attraction to this sort of tough thinking about money –– where anybody can make it and it’s your fault if you don’t.” – Source