Latest Posts • Latest Episodes • Free Tools

Credit Repair vs. Credit Fraud: Myth vs Reality

Quick Answer: Steve Rhode and Damon Day explain the difference between legitimate credit repair and illegal credit fraud. They cover how to dispute inaccurate information, why Credit Karma scores differ from real FICO scores, and the scams that could land you in serious legal trouble.

Listen to this episode:

Duration: 36 min

Before You Sign Anything: Run any debt relief contract through the free Contract Decoder to spot hidden fees and unfair terms. Check the company’s complaint history with the Scam-O-Meter.

Compare Your Real Options: Most debt relief companies won’t tell you about all your options — especially the ones they can’t profit from. Credit counseling has a 21-27% completion rate. Settlement resolves about 1% of enrolled debts fully. Chapter 7 bankruptcy generally ends in a discharge for individual filers in more than 99% of cases, excluding cases dismissed or converted (U.S. Courts) — and protects your retirement. Take the Find Your Path quiz for a recommendation based on your actual numbers.

Key Takeaways

  • Credit Karma Vantage 3.0 scores can differ from actual FICO scores by 100+ points
  • Your credit report should only contain accurate information – dispute anything incorrect
  • No credit is actually worse than bad credit for your FICO score
  • Keep credit utilization below 10% of available credit for maximum score impact
  • Credit repair companies cannot legally charge upfront fees before delivering results
  • Disputing old debts can reactivate collection efforts – be strategic
  • Different FICO versions (5, 6, 7, 8, 9) can produce different scores at the same bureau

Full Transcript

Click to expand transcript

Introduction: The Truth About Credit Repair

Steve Rhode: Hey, you’re listening to the Get Out of Debt Guy Show with myself, Steve Rhode from GetOutOfDebt.org and Damon Day from DamonDay.com. Today we’re going to be talking about credit repair, how to improve your credit score, scams to avoid, and what you should and should not do.

What Is Legitimate Credit Repair?

Steve Rhode: Damon, we’re talking about credit repair today. This is a subject that confuses a lot of people because they see these ads and they hear these things about how you can magically repair your credit. And the irony is that credit repair really is not that difficult, is it?

The part the headline left out

Each weekday I send one short email: one story that caught my attention, why it might matter to you, and one manageable thing you can do with it. A couple of minutes, and a dad joke.

In the latest issue (Nov 6): Owed money on an Amazon return? Check by Dec. 1

Free. I sell nothing. Unsubscribe any time.

Or read a few issues first

Damon Day: No, it depends on what your definition of credit repair is. But to do what a lot of these companies do is not that difficult. The goal for your credit report – the best example I have is you should think about your credit report like a report card in school. If you got A’s, that should be reported. If you got D’s, that should be reported. So a credit report is a credit report card.

What should NOT be on your credit report is information that is inaccurate, out of date, does not belong to you, and is just plain wrong. Now that’s stuff that can be disputed.

The Three Credit Bureaus and Your Scores

Steve Rhode: There are three major credit bureaus – Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion. One might have some of your accounts, another might have some, and the third might have a mix of both. The creditors normally only report to a credit bureau because they get a discount by reporting when they pull credit reports themselves.

Damon Day: I love Credit Karma. I think it’s a great tool. You can get your Equifax and your TransUnion report through Credit Karma. However, you can’t get your Experian. But the score that you see on Credit Karma is not your FICO score. It’s what they call a Vantage 3.0 score, which basically means nothing.

It’s an approximation – essentially a best guess that sucks – of what your actual credit score is because it will usually vary easily 100 points from your actual FICO.

How to Know Your Real FICO Score

Damon Day: If you pay money and actually go to myFICO.com, which is the actual FICO site, you can get your actual real FICO scores – the number that the bank will get when they pull your credit.

And your Vantage 3.0 score on Credit Karma might say 650, but your FICO might say 720. That makes a big difference. And then you’ll see you don’t just have one score – you’ve got a score for each bureau. Your Experian versus your TransUnion could also vary by 50, 60, 70 points.

The Dispute Process

Steve Rhode: If you have inaccurate information, you should follow each credit bureau’s dispute process. You can supply all relevant information and any documents to prove the information is incorrect.

The information will be reviewed, the creditor will verify the accuracy, they’ll provide a timely response, your credit report will be updated, and you’ll get a new free copy showing the disputed item is removed. It generally takes 30 to 45 days.

Damon Day: You can submit these disputes actually through Credit Karma or directly with annualcreditreport.com. Be conscious though – if you’re just going to start disputing things and you still owe money to these creditors, disputing it on your credit bureau could light the fire under the collector again to start blowing up your phone.

Building Credit After Problems

Steve Rhode: If you have old negative items – you were late on a bill, something happened – the more time that passes from that late payment, the less it impacts your score. One of the things people should focus on is having good new active lines of credit. Don’t rush out and close all of your old accounts. People make that mistake far too many times.

Damon Day: Your payment history is 35% of your credit score. Your credit history, how long you’ve had accounts, is 15%. So you don’t want to just close old accounts. And you don’t want to run up your balance more than 10% of your available credit to get the maximum score.

Secured Cards and Building Credit

Steve Rhode: If you want to improve your credit but nobody will give you credit right now, one option is a secured card. Damon, what’s a secured card?

Damon Day: It’s a card that you essentially put up your own collateral, which is usually cash, and they loan it back to you and charge you interest. You get a credit line that is reported on your credit bureau report that shows you are extended credit and you can prove you’re using it responsibly.

Credit Repair Scams to Avoid

Steve Rhode: The scams say “we’re going to make all the negative information go away.” I’ve actually seen people’s credit scores go DOWN after they do that, because no credit is worse than bad credit. It’s better to have bad credit than no credit.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau shut down Prime Marketing Holdings, Parkview Credit, National Credit Advisor and Credit Expert operations. They had 50,000 consumers that paid $20 million for their credit repair services.

If you do hire a credit repair outfit, they CANNOT charge you a fee until at least six months has passed from the time that you receive the benefit. That’s what the law is. So don’t fall for these advanced fee credit repair things.

Final Takeaways

Damon Day: When I hear “credit repair” – keep your expectations realistic. Before you think about hiring anybody, you should understand why your score is the way it is and whether or not it’s realistic to think it can improve, especially in a short amount of time.

Steve Rhode: If you think you’ve got a home purchase coming up in the next three or four months, talk to a mortgage broker as quickly as possible. Let them look at your credit score and give you guidance about what expectations you should have and what is the best strategy. Don’t wait till the last minute. Think ahead.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Credit Karma scores and real FICO scores?

Credit Karma uses Vantage 3.0 scoring, which is not the actual FICO score lenders use. Vantage scores can differ from real FICO scores by 100 points or more. To get your actual FICO score, you need to pay at myFICO.com.

Can I legally dispute accurate negative information on my credit report?

You can dispute anything, but the goal should be removing inaccurate, outdated, or fraudulent information – not accurate negative items. If information is accurate, it should stay on your report. Disputing accurate information is a gray area that could constitute fraud.

Why did my credit score go down after credit repair removed items?

No credit is actually worse than bad credit in FICO scoring. If a credit repair company removes all your negative items and you're left with no credit history, your score can actually drop. It's better to have imperfect history than no history.

Can credit repair companies charge upfront fees?

No. Under federal law, credit repair companies cannot charge fees until at least six months after you receive the benefit of their services. Any company charging upfront fees is violating the law.

What is a secured credit card and how does it help build credit?

A secured card requires you to deposit cash as collateral, which becomes your credit limit. The card activity is reported to credit bureaus, helping you establish or rebuild credit history. After responsible use, you may qualify for an unsecured card.

How do I find my actual FICO score before applying for a loan?

Use myFICO.com to get your actual FICO scores. Then call the lender and ask which credit bureau they pull from and which FICO version they use (8 or 9). This way you'll know your exact score before they pull your credit.

When does the Get Out of Debt Guy Show release new episodes?

The Get Out of Debt Guy Show releases new episodes every Thursday. Steve Rhode and Damon Day discuss debt solutions, credit repair, and consumer protection without shame-based advice.

author avatar
Steve Rhode The Get Out of Debt Guy | Consumer Debt Expert
Consumer debt expert & investigative writer. Personal bankruptcy survivor (1990). Washington Post award-winning author. Exposing debt scams since 1994.